Maryland case law › Johnson v. Farmers Bank

Johnson v. Farmers Bank

11 Md. 412 (1857) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from a contest over property claimed by an administrator de bonis non of the estate of Rinaido Johnson. The claimant sought to maintain a proceeding to recover property, but the court, in an opinion by Chief Judge Le Grand, affirmed the order below on the threshold ground that the claimant had no right to maintain the proceeding. The court held that neither at common law nor under the Maryland statute of 1798, chapter 101, did an administrator de bonis non have the right to claim property situated as was the property in contest. The right to maintain such an action, the court reasoned, is derived entirely from the act of 1820, chapter 174, which requires an order of the orphans court as a necessary preliminary step to the maintenance of such an action by an administrator de bonis non. Because that right had not been given in the present instance, and because of the circum
Questions presented
  • Whether an administrator de bonis non has the right to maintain a proceeding to claim property situated as is that which is the subject of the present contest, absent an order of the orphans court under the act of 1820, chapter 174.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. Apart from all considerations of want of proof, lapse of time, laches and limitations, we think the order appealed from ought to be affirmed, because the claimant has no right to maintain the proceeding. Neither at common law, nor under our statute of 1798, chapter 101, had an administrator de bonis non, the right to. claim property situated as is that which is the subject of the present contest. His right to maintain an action for such property, is derivable entirely through the act of 1820, ch. 174, which requires an order of the orphans court, as a necessary preliminary step to the maintainance of such an action by an administrator de bonis non.

That right has not been given in the present instance, and (judging from the circumstances and great lapse of time, characterizing the admin 415 istraliou of tbe estate of Rinaido Johnson,) it is but fair to presume, that were application now to be made to the Orphans court, for the authority permitted by the act of 1820, it would be refused. Order affirmed with costs.