Maryland case law › Kane v. Mayor of Baltimore

Kane v. Mayor of Baltimore

15 Md. 240 (1860) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: OtherTuck, J.⚠ Negative treatment (1)
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals of Maryland on appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Baltimore City. The appellant, Kane, challenged the condemnation of his property by the Mayor and City Council of Baltimore under the Act of 1853, which authorized the city to condemn land or water in fee simple when necessary for public purposes. The majority of the Court affirmed the judgment below, holding that the city had the power to condemn and that the necessity and expediency of the condemnation were legislative questions not subject to judicial review. Judge Tuck dissented, stating that while he agreed the city had the power to condemn under the Constitution and laws, and that the city authorities were the judges of the expediency and necessity, he dissented from the opinion of the court. The dissent does not elaborate on the specific grounds for disagreement beyond stating
Questions presented
  • Whether the Mayor and City Council of Baltimore have the power under the Constitution and laws to condemn land or water in fee simple when necessary to carry out the purposes of the Act of 1853.
  • Whether the city authorities' determination of expediency and necessity in a particular condemnation is subject to judicial review.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Tuck, J., delivered the following dissenting opinion: I propose, very briefly, to state wherein 1 dissent from the opinion of the court in this case. Under the Constitution and laws, the Mayor and City Council of Baltimore have power to condemn, in fee-simple, land or water, if there is a necessity for so doing, in order to cany out the purposes of the Act of 1853. This was admitted by the appellant’s counsel. That Act makes the city authorities judges of the expediency and necessity in the particular instance in which they may seek to assert their rights, and when they have made a condemnation, and it has been ratified by the proper court, the correctness of their judgment on that question cannot be reviewed by us. 1 deem it unnecessary to refer to the cases on the point, further than to say that, I think it fully sustained by some of those cited in argument.