Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: OtherEldridge, J. (dissenting)✓ Good law
SummaryThis opinion is a dissent by Judge Eldridge in Koshko v. Haining, 398 Md. 404 (2007). The dissent agrees with the Court that Maryland Code (1984, 2006 Repl. Vol.), § 9-102 of the Family Law Article is not facially unconstitutional, but disagrees with the remainder of the Court's opinion. The dissent argues that the majority, while claiming not to rely principally on Troxel v. Granville, 530 U.S. 57 (2000), actually places great reliance on Justice O'Connor's plurality opinion in Troxel, which was not an opinion of the Supreme Court and does not reflect the views of a majority of the Supreme Court. The dissent further contends that Troxel is not a sufficient basis for overruling several prior opinions of the Court of Appeals. The dissent also distinguishes McDermott v. Dougherty, 385 Md. 320 (2005), on which the majority relies, noting that McDermott was not a visitation case, did not inv
ELDRIDGE, J., dissenting: While I agree with the Court that Maryland Code (1984, 2006 Repl.Vol.), § 9-102, is not facially unconstitutional, I disagree with the remainder of the Court’s opinion. While the opinion states that the Court is not principally relying on Troxel v. Granville, 530 U.S. 57 , 120 S.Ct. 2054 , 147 L.Ed.2d 49 (2000), the Court actually places a great deal of reliance on Justice O’Connor’s opinion in Troxel . That opinion, however, was not an opinion of the Supreme Court and does not appear to reflect the views of a majority of the Supreme Court. Troxel is certainly not a sufficient basis for overruling several prior opinions by this Court.
McDermott v. Dougherty, 385 Md. 320 , 869 A.2d 751 (2005), on which the majority also relies, was not a visitation case, did not involve § 9-102 of the Family Law Article, and is quite distinguishable. Moreover, if I had sat in the McDermott case, I would have joined Judge Wilner’s concurring opinion.