Maryland case law › Kuenzel v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore

Kuenzel v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore

93 Md. 750 (1901) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedMcSherry, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryKuenzel v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore is a short per curiam-style opinion by Chief Judge McSherry disposing of an equity challenge to a municipal tax collection on jurisdictional grounds. The appellants sought an injunction to restrain the City of Baltimore from collecting taxes in the amount of seven dollars and thirty-two cents. The Court held that the amount in controversy was insufficient to confer equity jurisdiction under Article 16, Section 91 of the Code, which provides that courts of equity 'shall not hear, try, determine or give relief in any cause, matter or thing wherein the original debt or damages does not amount to twenty dollars.' The Court relied on its reasoning in the companion case Sindall v. Mayor and City Council, ante, p. 526, and on Reynolds v. Howard, 3 Md. Ch. Dec. 333, where a bill to restrain collection of unpaid purchase money pending payment of taxe
Questions presented
  • Whether a court of equity has jurisdiction to restrain the collection of a tax debt where the amount claimed is less than twenty dollars, as required by Article 16, Section 91 of the Code.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

The Court said : What has been said in Sindall v. Mayor and City Council, ante, p. 526, applies also to this case.' There is, however, one additional circumstance to be mentioned. The amount of taxes claimed by the city from the appellants is 751 only seven dollars and thirty-two cents. The appellants, seek an injunction to restrain the collection of that sum. Under Art. 16, Sec. pi of the Code, the amount involved is not sufficient to give a Court of equity jurisdiction.

The section reads : “The Court of equity in this State shall not hear, try, determine or give relief in any cause, matter or thing wherein the original debt or damages does not amount to twenty dollars.” In Reynolds v. Howard, 3 Md. Ch. Dec. 333, a bill in equity was filed by the purchaser of real estate to restrain two of the five vendors from proceeding with suits at law for the collection of their shares of the unpaid purchase-money, until the proportion of taxes which these two vendors owed on the land sold by them was paid by them. ■ The amount of unpaid taxes was less than twenty dollars, and on that ground the bill of complaint was dismissed. We do not see how the plaintiffs in this case can maintain a bill in equity to restrain the collection of a debt which amounts to only seven dollars and thirty-two cents. The decree dismissing the bill must therefore be affirmed. filed June 12th, 1901.

Bernard Carter, for the appellants. Wm. Pinkney Whyte and Olin Bryan, for the appellees. Opinion by McSherry, C. J.,