Maryland case law › Logan Tribe I. O. R. M. v. Schwartz

Logan Tribe I. O. R. M. v. Schwartz

19 Md. 565 (1863) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedBowie, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellee, widow of Simon Schwartz, sued the appellant, Logan Tribe I.O.R.M., to recover benefit dues she claimed were owed to her as the widow of a deceased member under the Society's Charter and By-Laws. After the evidence closed, the defendant requested a jury instruction that if Simon Schwartz was in arrears for weekly dues to the Society for more than three months as of April 1, 1856, and was also in arrears for other weekly dues for more than three months at the time of his death, then the plaintiff was not entitled to recover. The trial court refused this instruction, the jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff, and the defendant appealed. The Court of Appeals, in an opinion by Chief Judge Bowie, held that the defendant's prayer was based on a correct construction of the Charter and By-Laws. The Court reasoned that payment of the dues was a condition precedent to the plaintif
Questions presented
  • Whether the defendant's prayer was based upon a correct construction of the Charter and By-Laws of the Association under which the plaintiff claimed, such that the payment of dues was a condition precedent to the plaintiff's right to recover, and whether the fact of arrears was proper to be submitted to the jury with the instruction prayed.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Bowie, C. J., delivered the opinion of this Court: The appellee, widow of Simon Schwartz, instituted suit against the appellant, to recover certain benefit dues which she claimed to be owing to her, as widow of the deceased, 571 under tbo Charter and By-Laws of the Society of which her husband was a member. (Decided May 5th, 1863.) The defendant, the appellant, (after the evidence had been closed,) prayed the Court to instruct the jury, that if they believe from the evidence, Simon Schwartz, the appellee’s husband, was, on the 1st of April 1856, in arrear for weekly dues to the Society for more than three months, and was also in arrear for other weekly dues for more than three months, at the time of his death, then the plaintiff is not entitled to recover, which instruction the Court refused, and the judgment being for plaintiff, the defendant appealed. In the opinion of a majority of this Court, the defendant’s prayer was based upon a correct construction of the Charter and By-Laws of the Association under which the plaintiff claimed. The payment of the dues referred to, being a condition precedent to the plaintiff’s right to recover, whether the dues were in arrear or not, was a fact proper to be submitted to the jury, with the instruction prayed.

The Court having refused the same, the judgment below should he reversed, and procedendo awarded. Judgment reversed, and procedendo awarded.