Maryland case law › Maryland Farms Condominium Phase I, Inc. v. Pratt
Maryland Farms Condominium Phase I, Inc. v. Pratt
286 Md. 652 (1980) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Dismissed✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on a grant of certiorari to review the decision of the Court of Special Appeals in Pratt v. Maryland Farms Condominium, 42 Md. App. 632, 402 A.2d 105 (1979). The issue framed by the petitioner was: 'Does a landowner owe distinct duties of care to invitees with respect to an electrical easement and power line owned and maintained by a public utility?' The petition and answer did not inform the Court that the easement instrument was not part of the record. Without that instrument, the Court could not determine the precise relationship between the owner of the fee and the holder of the easement. Consequently, the Court was unable to address the issue for which certiorari was granted. The Court held that the writ of certiorari should be dismissed because the petition was improvidently granted. The Court did not reach the merits of the duty-of-care q
Questions presented
Does a landowner owe distinct duties of care to invitees with respect to an electrical easement and power line owned and maintained by a public utility?
Per Curiam: This case was before the Court of Special Appeals in Pratt v. Maryland Farms Condominium, 42 Md. App. 632 , 402 A.2d 105 (1979). We granted certiorari in order that we might address the issue framed by the petitioner, “Does a landowner owe distinct duties of care to invitees with respect to an electrical easement and power line owned and 653 maintained by a public utility?” The petition and answer did not inform us that the easement is not a part of the record in the case. Without that instrument we do not know the precise relationship between the owner of the fee and the holder of the easement. Thus we are unable to address the issue for which we granted the petition.
It follows, therefore, that the writ of certiorari should be dismissed, the petition having been improvidently granted. It is so ordered. Petitioner to pay the costs.