Maryland case law › McDonald v. Director of Patuxent Institution
McDonald v. Director of Patuxent Institution
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryMcDonald filed an application for leave to appeal from a determination that he was a defective delinquent under Maryland's defective delinquency statute. He attacked the constitutionality of the Act on several grounds. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, held that all of his constitutional contentions were foreclosed by prior decisions of the Court. The Court cited Eggleston v. State, 209 Md. 504; Meredith v. Director, 226 Md. 653; Simmons v. Director, 227 Md. 661; McDonogh v. Director, 229 Md. 626; and Williams v. Director, 232 Md. 632, as answering his arguments. The applicant also relied on Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660, but the Court found that case clearly distinguishable on the facts. The Court did not elaborate on the specific constitutional grounds raised or the reasoning of the prior cases, simply stating that they were controlling. The application for leave to
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether the Maryland defective delinquency statute is unconstitutional on several grounds raised by the applicant.
Per Curiam. This application for leave to appeal from a determination of defective delinquency attacks the constitutionality of the Act on several grounds. His contentions are all answered by prior decisions of this Court. See Eggleston v. State, 209 Md. 504 ; Meredith v. Director, 226 Md. 653 ; Simmons v. Director, 227 Md. 661; McDonogh v. Director, 229 Md. 626 ; Williams v. Director, 232 Md. 632 .
Robinson v. California, 370 U. S. 660 , relied on by the applicant is clearly distinguishable on the facts. Application denied.