Maryland case law › McIver v. State

McIver v. State

456 Md. 270 (2017) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Remanded✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from a speed camera infraction issued to Respondent under Md. Code, Transportation Article § 21-809(c), which carries a civil penalty not exceeding $40. After proceedings in the District Court of Maryland, sitting in Montgomery County, a default judgment was entered against Respondent. Respondent appealed to the Circuit Court for Montgomery County, which erroneously assigned the case to its criminal docket (designated criminal case no. 129917-C) and set a pre-trial hearing. When Respondent failed to appear, the Circuit Court presumably dismissed or otherwise disposed of the case. Respondent then appealed to the Court of Special Appeals, which transferred the appeal to the Court of Appeals pursuant to Md. Code, Courts & Judicial Proceedings Article § 12-302(a) and Md. Rule 8-132. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam order, held that the District Court has exclusive civil
Questions presented
  • Whether the Circuit Court for Montgomery County erred in assigning the speed camera infraction case to its criminal docket rather than its civil docket, given that the District Court has exclusive civil jurisdiction over such infractions under Md. Code, Courts & Judicial Proceedings Article § 4-401(13) and the penalty is civil under Transportation Article § 21-809(c).
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

ORDER WHEREAS, a supplemental petition for writ of certiorari having been filed by Petitioner and granted by this Court with a writ of certiorari being issued on November 3, 2017; and WHEREAS, Respondent was issued a citation for a speed camera infraction, which carries a civil penalty not exceeding $40, pursuant to Sec. 21—809(c) of the Transportation Article; and as a result of proceedings held in the District Court of Maryland, sitting in Montgomery County, the charges against Respondent ended in a default judgment. Thereafter, Respondent noted an appeal to the Circuit Court for Montgomery County; and WHEREAS, the Circuit Court for Montgomery County did not assign the case to its civil docket but instead assigned the case to its criminal docket and designated it criminal case no. 129917-C and set the matter for a pre-trial hearing; a hearing at which the Respondent failed to appear. Thereafter, Respondent noted an appeal to the Court of Special Appeals; and WHEREAS, the Court of Special Appeals transferred to this Court on August 7, 2017 the above captioned appeal pursuant to Sec. 12-302(a) of the Courts & Judicial Proceedings Article, and Md. Rule 8-132; and WHEREAS, Sec. 4-401(13) of the Courts & Judicial Proceedings Article provides that the District Court has exclusive civil jurisdiction in a proceeding for a civil infraction under Sec. 21-809(c) of the Transportation Article; and WHEREAS, Sec. 21-809(c)(2) of the Transportation Article provides, in part, that a driver of a motor vehicle is subject to a civil penalty if a motor vehicle is recorded by a speed-monitoring system while being operated in violation of the law, it is this 16th day of November, 2017, ORDERED, by the Court of Appeals of Maryland, that this case be, and it is hereby, remanded to the Circuit Court for Montgomery County for further civil proceedings with the appropriate parties pursuant to Sec. 4—401(18) of the Courts & Judicial Proceedings Article and Sec. 21-809 of the Transportation Article; and it is further, ORDERED, that this case be unsealed and the record in this case be corrected by designating it as a civil, rather than a criminal, proceeding nunc pro tunc.