Maryland case law › Merchants Insurance v. Alexander Brown & Sons

Merchants Insurance v. Alexander Brown & Sons

77 Md. 79 (1893) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: ReversedBryan, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case is a companion to a preceding case and is materially identical except for one clause of forfeiture in the insurance policy. The policy provided that it would be void 'if, with the knowledge of the insured, foreclosure proceedings be commenced or notice given of sale of any property covered by this policy by virtue of any mortgage or trust deed.' The defendant requested a jury instruction (its second prayer) asserting that the proceedings for sale under a power contained in a mortgage constituted such a notice of sale under a mortgage or trust deed as was contemplated by the forfeiture clause. The trial court rejected the prayer and the defendant excepted. On appeal, the Court of Appeals, speaking through Judge Bryan, held that the language of the policy is clear and distinct and must be given effect. The Court concluded that the defendant's second prayer ought to have been gran
Questions presented
  • Did the proceedings for sale under the power contained in the mortgage constitute such a notice of sale under a mortgage or trust deed as was meant by the clause of forfeiture in the policy?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Bryan, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This case is similar to the preceding one in all material particulars, except in one of the clauses of for 80 feiture contained in the policy. This clause makes the policy void, “if, with the knowledge of the insured, foreclosure proceedings be commenced or notice given of sale of any property covered by this policy by virtue of any mortgage or trust deed.” The defendant’s second prayer presents the defence that the proceedings for sale under the power contained in the mortgage showed such a notice of sale under a mortgage or trust deed as was meant by this clause of forfeiture. It was rejected by the Court and defendant excepted.

The language of the policy is clear and distinct and we must give effect to it. The prayer ought to have been granted. As the plaintiffs’ cause of action is defeated by the operation of this clause, the judgment must be reversed without a new trial. (Decided 19th January, 1893.) Judgment reversed.