Maryland case law › Merrick v. Mayor of Baltimore

Merrick v. Mayor of Baltimore

43 Md. 219 (1875) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from a special statutory proceeding initiated under Acts of Assembly and Ordinances of Baltimore City to condemn certain property. A jury of inquisition rendered a verdict, and the clerk of the court entered a judgment upon that verdict. The appellees (the Mayor and City Council of Baltimore) moved to strike out the judgment, arguing that the court had no authority to enter such a judgment in a special proceeding governed entirely by statute. The court below denied the motion to strike, and also overruled an application for a mandamus. On appeal, the Court of Appeals held that the motion to strike the judgment should have prevailed. The Court reasoned that the Acts of Assembly and Ordinances under which the proceedings were had conferred no authority upon the court to enter a judgment; the proceeding was a special one governed entirely by statutory provisions, which conte
Questions presented
  • Whether the court below erred in refusing to strike out the judgment entered upon the inquisition of the jury.
  • Whether the court below erred in overruling the application for a mandamus.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

By the Court :— In this case we think the motion made by the appellees, to strike out the judgment, entered upon the inquisition of the jury, ought to have prevailed. There is no authority conferred upon the Court to enter such judgment by the Acts of Assembly or Ordinances under which the proceedings were had; and the same being a special proceeding under the statutes, are governed entirely by the statutory provisions, which do not contemplate the entering of any judgment by the Court; but provide that the verdict of the jury shall he conclusive, and that the same with the other proceedings shall he certified to the City Register. The judgment having been entered inadvertently by the clerk, without authority, ought to have been stricken out. In the case of The State vs. Graves, 19 Md., 351, where the proceedings were of the same kind, a judgment had been entered; hut no notice was taken of that entry, either by the Court or counsel; nor was any question made or 246 discussed with regard to it.

That case cannot, therefore, be considered as any authority for the practice of entering a judgment in such cases. No appeal, however, having been taken from the order of the Court below in this respect, the order stands unreversed. (Decided 24th June, 1875.) Upon the main question presented by the appeal, which arises upon the order overruling the application for a man-: damns, we concur in the views expressed by the Judge of the City Court, and for the reasons stated in his opinion sent up with the record, the order will be affirmed. Order affirmed.