Maryland case law › Miller v. Proprietary
Miller v. Proprietary
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Reversed✓ Good law
SummaryThis brief opinion fragment addresses a narrow evidentiary/procedural point concerning summary convictions before Justices of the Peace. The court considers the authority of Bewdley, 1 P. Wms. 223 (also cited in Strange 102), for the proposition that a practice may prevail against an act of Parliament, and the statement in 1 Bacon's Abridgment 194 that a conviction before Justices on proof or confession may be reversed without a writ of error. The court explains that the Bacon passage does not support the contrary argument; its meaning is only that in summary proceedings no writ of error is necessary, not that the conviction is thereby erroneous. The court observes that there is scarcely any other way to convict persons but by proof or confession, citing 2 Jones 167, and that all convictions before Justices of the Peace in a summary way are on proof or on confession. The opinion conclude
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether a conviction before Justices of the Peace on proof or confession may be reversed without a writ of error, and whether the authority in 1 Bacon's Abridgment 194 supports the argument that such a conviction is erroneous.
In the case of Bewdley, 1 P. Wms. 223. also cited in Stra. 102. a practice was held to prevail against an act of Parliament. In 1 Bac. Abr. 194. it is said, that a conviction before Justices, on proof or confession, may be reversed without a writ of error. Perhaps this case may be cited on the other side ; but the meaning of it is no more than this: that in these summary proceedings there is no occasion for a writ of error ; but it by no means proves the case erroneous, for there is scarce any other way to convict persons but by proof or confession; 2 Jones, 167 . and it is evident that all convictions before Justices of the Peace, in a summary way, are on proof or on confession.
The Provincial Court reversed the judgment.