Maryland case law › Moore v. Avocet Development Corp.

Moore v. Avocet Development Corp.

292 Md. 593 (1982) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Vacated✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from a defamation action filed by respondent Avocet Development Corporation against petitioner Mary Anne Moore. The Court of Special Appeals issued an unreported opinion, and Moore sought certiorari in the Court of Appeals to address important public issues in defamation law. Before briefing in the Court of Appeals, Avocet had a change of heart and moved to dismiss its cause of action with prejudice, desiring to start the new year on a clean slate. Moore opposed the dismissal, concerned that the unreported opinion might be relied upon as precedent for harassing lawsuits. The Court of Appeals granted certiorari but, faced with Avocet's abandonment of its claim, held that the plaintiff should be permitted to dismiss its action. The Court reasoned that the issues raised became moot and that the unreported opinion could not be cited as authority under its rules, so Moore's fe
Questions presented
  • Whether the Court should permit the respondent to dismiss its cause of action with prejudice when the petitioner opposes the dismissal due to concerns about the unreported opinion being relied upon as precedent.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam: We granted the writ of certiorari in this case in order that we might address important public issues relative to the law of defamation. However, before the filing of a brief in this Court respondent Avocet Development Corporation, the 594 original plaintiff, had a change of heart. It announced a desire to dismiss its cause of action and to start the new year on a clean slate. To that end, it moved to dismiss the appeal with prejudice.

Petitioner Mary Anne Moore has resisted. She is disturbed by the unreported opinion of the Court of Special Appeals and fears that others "may rely upon the erroneous decision by the Court of Special Appeals as justification for harassing lawsuits.” The fear is misplaced since under our rules it may not be cited as authority. We are of the view that if the party plaintiff wishes to abandon its claim it should be permitted to do so and the issues raised thus become moot. Judgment of the Court of Special Appeals vacated and case remanded to that Court for further remand to the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County for purpose of entry of a judgment of non pros in favor of the defendant against the plaintiff for costs, pursuant to the request of appellee, the plaintiff in that proceeding.

Costs in this Court to be paid by appellee.