Maryland case law › Nation-Wide Check Corp. v. Sherman

Nation-Wide Check Corp. v. Sherman

268 Md. 1 (1973) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Vacated✓ Good law
SummaryThe plaintiff appealed from a "judgment by default" entered against it as a sanction for failing to answer interrogatories propounded by the defendant over a substantial lapse of time. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, held that there can be no judgment by default against a plaintiff under Maryland practice. The proper sanction under Maryland Rule 417 d, applicable to a plaintiff who fails to answer interrogatories, is dismissal of the action—i.e., a judgment of non pros. The entry of a "judgment by default" against the plaintiff was therefore a nullity. The Court emphasized that closer study of the Maryland Rules, adherence to the forms in the appendix, and timely answers to interrogatories would have avoided the need for the opinion. The interests of justice required a prompt trial on the merits upon remand. The order was vacated and the case remanded for trial, with the a
Questions presented
  • Whether a judgment by default may be entered against a plaintiff for failure to answer interrogatories under Maryland Rule 417 d.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam : Closer study by counsel for the parties of the Maryland Rules, closer adherence to the forms appearing in the appendix to those rules, and answers to interrogatories in accordance with the time schedule set in those rules would have avoided the necessity for this opinion. 2 This case reaches us by way of appeal by the plaintiff from “judgment by default” entered against it because of its failure to answer interrogatories propounded by the defendant, despite a substantial lapse of time. There can be no judgment by default against a plaintiff. The sanction provided under Maryland Rule 417 d properly applicable to the plaintiff-appellant here was for the trial court to “dismiss the action.” In other words, to enter a judgment of non pros. See 2 Poe, Pleading & Practice §§ 362 and 365, at 348-351 (5th ed.

Tiffany 1925). Entry of “judgment by default” was a nullity. The interests of justice dictate prompt trial on the merits upon the remand. Order vacated and case remanded for trial; appellant to pay the costs.