Maryland case law › Nelson v. Pierson

Nelson v. Pierson

8 Md. 300 (1855) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: RemandedTuck✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal arose from an insolvency proceeding in the Court of Common Pleas, where the appellant, a trustee in insolvency, sought compensation for professional services rendered to the estate. The court, speaking through Tuck, J., agreed with the lower court that a trustee in insolvency cannot employ a professional adviser and charge that adviser's compensation to the estate. However, the court recognized an exception: where the assistance of counsel is required in prosecuting or defending the interests of the creditors, such fees are properly payable out of the funds. The proof showed that the appellant had attended professionally to many cases before justices of the peace, but the record did not establish the extent, character, or value of those services. The court held that when the case was remanded to the auditor for further proof of claims, the appellant should have been allowed t
Questions presented
  • Whether a trustee in insolvency can employ a professional adviser and charge his compensation to the estate.
  • Whether the appellant should have been allowed to make good his claim for professional services by showing the extent and character of his services and the value thereof.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Tuck, J., delivered the opinion of this court. We agree with the Court of Common Pleas, that a trustee in insolvency cannot employ a professional adviser and charge his compensation to the estate. But where the assistance of 301 counsel is required in prosecuting or defending the interests of the creditors, they are properly payable out of the funds. Young’s Appeal, 8 Gill, 286 .

The proof shows, that there were many cases before justices of the peace, to all or some of which the appellant attended professionally. We think when the case was remanded to the auditor for further proof of claims, liberty should have been allowed to the appellant to make good his claim, by showing the extent and character of his services and the value thereof. The record will be remanded under the act of 1849, ch. 88, that further proceedings may be had according to the views here expressed. The costs should be paid out of the estate.

Cause remanded.