Maryland case law › Nicholson v. Sligh

Nicholson v. Sligh

1 Md. 434 (1772) · Maryland Court of Appeals (Provincial Court)
Maryland Court of Appeals (Provincial Court)Disposition: Other✓ Good law
SummaryThis cause came before the Justices on a motion to quash a fieri facias. The Justices present were at a loss to determine the points, and at their request the whole matter was referred to James Hollyday and Thomas Johnson, Esquires, two gentlemen of the bar not engaged in the cause, for their opinions. Both were of opinion that the fieri facias ought to be quashed. They assigned as the reason for their opinion that unless the debtor showed his effects, the creditor could only proceed to execute the fieri facias at common law, and it not appearing that the debtor had done this, the proceedings were erroneous. Mr. Johnson further observed that he thought the sheriff could not amend the return so as to give any other or further effect to the return of the appraisers, for the reasons assigned by the defendant's counsel. The court thereupon entered judgment that the fieri facias be quashed.
Questions presented
  • Whether the fieri facias ought to be quashed where it did not appear that the debtor had shown his effects?
  • Whether the sheriff could amend the return so as to give any other or further effect to the return of the appraisers?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

437 It appears, from the notes of T. Jenings, Esq. who was counsel in this cause, and of W. Cooke, Esq. that the Justices present being at a loss to determine the points, desired that the opinions of some of the gentlemen of the bar, not engaged in the cause, might be taken; and thereupon the whole matter was referred to James Holly day and Thomas Johnson, Esquires, who were both of opinion that the fieri facias ought to be quashed, assigning for the reason of their opinion, that unless the debtor shewed his effects, the creditor could only proceed to execute the fieri facias at common law, and it not appearing that the debtor had done this, the proceedings were erroneous. Mr. Johnson, in addition, further observed, that he thought the sheriff could not amend the return so as to give any other or further effect to the return of the appraisers, for the reasons assigned by the defendant’s counsel. ' Judgment that the fieri facias be quashed.