Maryland case law › O'KEEFE v. Scott
O'KEEFE v. Scott
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DismissedHenderson✓ Good law
SummaryThis is an appeal in an action at law founded upon the unauthorized publication of a photograph of the plaintiff upon the cover of a visitors' guide to Ocean City. The appeal was taken from "the order sustaining the demurrer and the judgment in this case." However, the Court of Appeals, speaking through Henderson, J., observed that it appears from the docket entries in the transcript that no judgment was entered after the demurrer was sustained. Because no final judgment had been entered, the appeal was premature. The Court relied on settled Maryland authority holding that an appeal does not lie from an order sustaining a demurrer absent the entry of judgment. Accordingly, the Court did not reach the merits of the underlying tort claim concerning unauthorized publication of the plaintiff's photograph. The sole question decided was the appealability of the order. The Court dismissed the a
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether the appeal is premature where no judgment was entered after the demurrer was sustained.
Henderson, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This appeal is from “the order sustaining the demurrer and the judgment in this case”, in an action at law founded upon the unauthorized publication of a photograph of the plaintiff upon the cover of a visitors’ guide to Ocean City. But it appears from the docket entries in the transcript that no judgment was entered after 311 the demurrer was sustained. The appeal is premature and must be dismissed.
Ernst v. Keough, 197 Md. 554, 556 , 80 A. 2d 23, 24 ; Montgomery County Welfare Board v. Donnally, 195 Md. 442 , 73 A. 2d 505 ; Goodman v. Clark, 193 Md. 521 , 69 A. 2d 496 ; Penny v. Maryland State Police, 186 Md. 10 , 45 A. 2d 741 . Appeal dismissed, with costs.