Maryland case law › Orme v. Williams

Orme v. Williams

47 Md. 552 (1878) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: DismissedStewart✓ Good law
SummaryOrme v. Williams came before the Maryland Court of Appeals on an appeal from the Baltimore City Court, which had affirmed a judgment rendered by a justice of the peace. The action apparently arose on a promissory note, and the jurisdictional dispute centered on whether the amount in controversy exceeded the justice of the peace's statutory limit. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Judge Stewart, held that the justice's jurisdiction is determined by the sum proved to be due, not by the face amount of the note. The record disclosed that the justice and the Baltimore City Court, upon the proof, found the balance due after credits to be $96.19, an amount within the justice's jurisdiction. Because the judgment of the Baltimore City Court was final in such cases, no appeal lay to the Court of Appeals. The Court further noted that the jurisdictional question argued at the bar was not presen
Questions presented
  • Whether the jurisdiction of the justice of the peace depends upon the sum proved to be due or upon the amount appearing on the face of the note.
  • Whether an appeal lies to the Court of Appeals from the judgment of the Baltimore City Court in a case originating before a justice of the peace where the amount found due is within the justice's jurisdiction.
  • Whether the question of jurisdiction argued at the bar is presented by the record and can be considered by the Court of Appeals.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Stewart, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The jurisdiction of the justice of the peace in this case depends upon the sum proved to be due, and not upon the amount appearing on the face of the note. So far as the record discloses, the justice of the peace and the Baltimore City Court decided upon the proof, that the balance due after the deduction of credits was $96.19 ; which was within the jurisdiction of the justice of the peace, and the judgment of Baltimore City Court being final, no appeal lies to this Court. But the question of jurisdiction argued at the bar is not presented by the record.

Bills of exceptions are not allowed in such cases, and cannot be considered by this Court. Cole vs. Hynes, 46 Md., 181 . Appeal dismissed.