Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedMason, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on appeal from a judgment convicting the defendant of fornication. The record showed that the offense was perpetrated in the State of Pennsylvania. The court, speaking through Mason, J., reversed the judgment. The court relied on the prior decision in Oldham v. State, 5 Gill 90, which held that a proceeding of this kind is a criminal proceeding under the Act of 1781, ch. 13, and that its object is to punish persons guilty of fornication. The court rejected the argument that the sole purpose of the law was to indemnify the county, quoting Oldham for the proposition that the design of the law to indemnify the county does not change the character of the proceeding. Because fornication was the offense designed to be punished, and because the record showed the offense was committed in Pennsylvania, the court held that no indictment would lie in Maryl
Questions presented
Whether a proceeding for fornication under the Act of 1781, ch. 13, is a criminal proceeding, and whether an indictment will lie in this State when the offense was perpetrated in the State of Pennsylvania.
Mason, J., delivered the opinion of this court. The judgment in this casé must be reversed. The case of Oldham vs. The State, 5 Gill, 90 , settles the question, that a proceeding of this kind is a criminal proceeding, under the act of 1781, ch. 13, and that its object is to punish “persons guilty of fornication.” In the case referred to, the court emphatically meets the point, raised upon this appeal, (that indemnity to the county was the sole purpose of the law,) when they say, “that the design of the law, in'the punishment inflicted, was to indemnify the county, does not in the least change the character of the proceeding.” ■ Fornication then being the offence designed to be punished, and as the record shows that the offence was perpetrated in the State of Pennsylvania, no indictment will, therefore, lie in this State. Judgment reversed but no procedendo awarded.