Maryland case law › Paine v. France

Paine v. France

26 Md. 46 (1866) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: OtherBartol, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Maryland Court of Appeals on a motion by the appellant to reopen a decree and rehear the cause. The Court, after examining its prior opinion, the record, and notes of argument, and after consultation with members who had not participated in the former decision, concluded that the motion should not be granted. The Court found no error in its prior rulings. The appellant suggested that the Court should not have passed a final decree but instead, under Code Art. 5, sec. 28, should have remanded the cause without affirming or reversing so that the complainant could proceed under an amended bill. The Court stated that this suggestion would be entitled to great weight if it appeared that the purposes of justice would be advanced or that the complainant would be entitled to relief under an amended bill. However, the record contained an agreement setting forth that by t
Questions presented
  • Whether the Court ought to re-open the decree heretofore passed and re-hear the cause.
  • Whether the Court ought not to have passed a final decree, but under the Code, Art. 5, sec. 28, the cause ought to have been remanded without affirming or reversing, so that the complainant might proceed under an amended bill.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Bartol, J., delivered the opinion of this Court. The Court have considered the motion filed in this ease hy the appellant, “to re-open the decree heretofore passed therein and to re-hear the cause,” and have carefully •examined the opinion heretofore pronounced, together with the record and notes of argument, and have, upon consultation with the other members of the Court who did not sit at the hearing or participate in the former decision, come to the conclusion that the motion ought not to be granted. In the judgment of the Court there was no error in their ruling upon the questions decided. 47 ( Decided November 2nd, 1866.) The suggestion 'that the Court ought not to have passed a final decree, but that under the Code, Art. 5, sec. 28,, the cause ought to have been remanded without affirming or reversing, so that the complainant might proceed under an amended bill, would be entitled to great weight if it appeared to this Court that the purposes of justice would thus he advanced, or that he would he entitled to relief under an amended bill. The record contained an agreement setting forth that by the laws of all the other States, the sale of lottery tickets within their limits was forbidden.

And in the opinion of this Court, this admission presents an insuperable obstacle to the complainant’s recovery under any state of pleading. A Court of Equity in Maryland will not entertain a suit based upon a contract or transactions involving a violation of the laws of our sister States within their limits. The complainant in this case therefore would not be entitled to relief in respect to the sales of lottery tickets out of the limits of Maryland ; his case would not be aided by an amendment of the bill so as to make it conform to the evidence offered. Motion overruled.