Maryland case law › Parsons v. Hughes

Parsons v. Hughes

12 Md. 1 (1858) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedTuck, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis is an appeal from an order granting an injunction. The bill alleged that the debtor had mortgaged real and personal property and was committing waste or destroying the mortgaged property. The court, on the bill alone (the answer not being considered on this interlocutory appeal), held that the order granting the injunction was properly granted. The Court of Appeals recognized the well-established power of a court of equity to interfere by injunction to prevent waste or destruction of property covered by mortgages. It noted that this power had been frequently exercised and was recognized in Clagett v. Salmon, 5 G. & J., 314, where the bill was filed before the mortgagee was entitled to proceed to recover the debt. The court reasoned that the same principle applies after default made by the debtor, because the mortgagee is not bound to take possession of the property by process at law
Questions presented
  • Whether the court has power to interfere by injunction to prevent waste or destruction of property covered by mortgages, especially after default by the debtor.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Tuck, J., delivered the opinion of this court. This is an appeal from an order granting an injunction, and must be determined on the bill, without reference to the answer. McCann vs. Taylor, 10 Md. Rep., 429 . Upon carefully considering the averments of the bill, which on this hearing must be taken as true, we are of opinion that the order was properly granted.

It is unnecessary to multiply authorities on the question of the court’s power to interfere by injunction to prevent waste or destruction of property covered by mortgages. It has been frequently exercised, and was recognized in Clagett vs. Salmon, 5 G. & J., 314, where the bill was filed before the mortgagee was entitled to proceed to recover the debt. The same principle applies after default made by the debtor, for the mortgagee is not bound to take possession of the property by process at law. He may elect to prosecute his remedy in equity, and the debtor ought not to complain of being restrained from impairing the security which is held by his creditor.

The subject was before the late chan 6 cellor, in a case where real and personal property were both conveyed by mortgage, and the debtor was selling and misapplying the personalty. Brown vs. Stewart, 1 Md. Ch. Dec., 87. Concurring in the views there expressed, we are willing to rest our affirmance of the present order on the chancellor’s opinion.

(Decided June 2nd, 1858.) Order affirmed and cause reminded.