Maryland case law › Peltz v. American Loan Co.

Peltz v. American Loan Co.

148 Md. 390 (1925) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Dismissed✓ Good law
SummaryIn these consolidated cases, the defendant attempted to appeal from orders sustaining demurrers to his third and fourth pleas to the seventh count of the plaintiff's declarations, and to amended fourth pleas to the same count. The trial court entered judgments on the demurrers in favor of the plaintiff for costs. The defendant noted appeals from those rulings. The plaintiff moved to dismiss the appeals. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, held that the appeals were premature because the cases remained at issue and ready for trial on other pleas, and the defendant had no right of appeal at that stage. The Court relied on Emersonian Apartments v. Taylor, 132 Md. 209, where the identical situation was presented and it was held that the defendant had no right of appeal. The Court granted the motions to dismiss the appeals with costs to the appellee. The legal question was whether
Questions presented
  • Whether the defendant has a right of appeal from rulings against him on demurrers to his third and fourth pleas to the seventh count of the plaintiff's declarations, and to the amended fourth pleas to the same count, where other pleas remain and the cases are at issue and ready for trial.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

The following per curiam opinion was delivered: The motions to dismiss the appeals in these cases must be granted. 'The appeals -are taken by 'the defendant from rulings against him on demurrers to his third and fourth pleas to the seventh count of the plaintiff’s declarations in suits at common law, and to the amended fourth pleas to the same count. The demurrers were sustained and entries made: “Judgment on the demurrer * * * in .favor of the plaintiff for costs.” There were other pleas in the cases, and without 391 those to Which demurrers were sustained, the eases appear to he alt issue and ready for trial. In the ease of Emersonian Apartments v. Taylor, 132 Md. 209 , exactly the same situation existed and it was held that the defendant 'had no right of appeal at that stage of the case. Appeals dismissed luith costs to the appellee.