Maryland case law › Perkerson v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Perkerson v. Director of Patuxent Institution

239 Md. 142 (1965) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedHammond✓ Good law
SummaryPerkerson, convicted of burglary in 1957 and confined at Patuxent Institution since 1958 when first found a defective delinquent, applied for leave to appeal from a January 1965 redetermination by Judge Manley that he continued to be a defective delinquent. He raised two contentions: (1) inadequate representation because his lawyer failed to advise him of his right to a jury trial and conferred with him only twenty-five minutes before the hearing; and (2) insufficiency of the evidence. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam-style opinion by Hammond, J., rejected both. On the representation claim, the Court held that a bare allegation of failure to advise of the jury trial right, without any assertion that he would have requested a jury or that a jury would have differed from the court, does not establish inadequate representation; trial by the court is customary and normal in Maryland in
Questions presented
  • Whether Perkerson was inadequately represented below because his lawyer failed to advise him of his right to a jury trial and failed to adequately prepare his case, conferring with him for only twenty-five minutes at Patuxent.
  • Whether there was evidence sufficient to support the trial court's finding that Perkerson continued to be a defective delinquent.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Hammond, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Perkerson, the applicant for leave to appeal from a redetermination of his status as a defective delinquent by Judge Manley in January 1965, was convicted of burglary in 1957 and has been in Patuxent since 1958 when he was first found to be a defective delinquent by Judge Cullen. The applicant makes two contentions of error. First, that he was inadequately represented below, in that his lawyer failed to advise him of his right to a jury trial and failed to adequately prepare his case, conferring with him for only twenty-five minutes at Patuxent; and, second, that there was no evidence sufficient to support the trial court’s finding.

Perkerson cannot prevail on either contention. He makes only the bare allegation that he was not advised of his right to a jury trial but does not allege or attempt to show that he would have asked for a jury trial had he known he could have, or suggest why a jury’s verdict would have differed from that of Judge Manley. No actual unfairness in the trial by the court is claimed, and a trial by the court is a customary and normal practice in Maryland in criminal as well as civil cases. Grammer v. State, 203 Md. 200, 213 , quoting Rose v. State, 177 Md. 577, 581 .

The fact that Perkerson’s lawyer talked to him for only twenty-five minutes before the trial does not show inadequate representation. The background and relevant facts of the case were almost completely, if not completely, revealed by the records and reports which were available to and, it would appear, were utilized by the applicant’s lawyer. Cf. Washington v. Director, 237 Md. 311 .

Indeed, there was little available to Perkerson to counter the State’s contention that the applicant continued to be a defective delinquent. Dr. Lerner, the psychiatrist who had examined Perkerson before the first hearing was again engaged by the State at the request of Perkerson to examine him. His professional opinion was that Perkerson was a defective delinquent who was not presently ready for release. 144 The contention that the evidence was insufficient because the State’s only witness, Dr. Boslow, based his opinion that the applicant was a defective delinquent in part on the examinations and reports of others and this method of producing testimony unconstitutionally deprived him of the right of confrontation and cross-examination, has been rejected repeatedly by this Court. Oppel v. Director, 237 Md. 611; Ash v. Director, 237 Md. 443, 444.

The applicant had a right to summon any person whose report on examination was relied on. Code, (1964 Cum. Supp.), Art. 31B, Sec. 10 (a) and see Brunson v. Director, 229 Md. 128. Dr. Boslow’s opinion was sufficient to support a finding of defective delinquency if the trier of fact accepted it, as he did.

Application denied.