Maryland case law › Presley v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Presley v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

205 Md. 660 (2001) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedHammond✓ Good law
SummaryPresley sought leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus by Judge Cullen of the Supreme Bench of Baltimore City. He had been convicted of larceny in the Criminal Court of Baltimore in May 1952 and sentenced to five years in the Maryland Penitentiary. He raised three contentions: (1) illegal search, seizure, and arrest; (2) police use of force and threats to obtain incriminating statements; and (3) denial of counsel. The Court, speaking through Judge Hammond, held that none of these grounds could be raised on habeas corpus. The legality of a search and seizure may be raised on appeal but not on habeas corpus, citing Sykes v. Warden, Dodson v. Warden, Presley v. Warden, Laslo v. Warden, and Barr v. Warden. The legality of arrest likewise cannot be raised on habeas corpus, citing Spence v. Warden, Lewis v. Warden, and Cumberland v. Warden. Allegations that police used force
Questions presented
  • Whether the legality of a search and seizure may be raised on habeas corpus.
  • Whether the legality of an arrest may be raised on habeas corpus.
  • Whether allegations that police used force and threats to gain incriminating statements may be raised on habeas corpus.
  • Whether a contention that petitioner was deprived of counsel may be raised on habeas corpus.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Hammond, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is an application for leave to appeal from a denial of a writ of habeas corpus by Judge Cullen of the Supreme Bench of Baltimore City. The petitioner was convicted in the Criminal Court of Baltimore in May, 1952, of larceny, and was sentenced to the Maryland Penitentiary for five years. Petitioner bases his right to relief upon three contentions: that there was an illegal search, seizure and arrest; that the police used force and threats to gain incriminating statements from him; and that he was denied counsel.

This Court has repeatedly stated that the legality of a search and seizure may be raised on appeal but cannot be raised on habeas corpus. Sykes v. Warden, 201 Md. 662 ; Dodson v. Warden, 201 Md. 655 ; Presley v. Warden, 201 Md. 660 ; Laslo v. Warden, 204 Md. 663 ; Barr v. Warden, 200 Md. 657 ; nor can the legality of arrest—see Spence v. Warden, 204 Md. 661 ; Lewis v. Warden, 203 Md. 676 ; Cumberland v. Warden, 205 Md. 646 ; nor can his allegations that the police used force and threats to gain incriminating statements from him be raised on habeas corpus —see Freeland v. Warden, 193 Md. 696 , certiorari denied, 338 U. S. 836 , 94 L. Ed. 511 . See also Goodman v. Warden, 190 Md. 746 , certiorari denied, 335 U. S. 847 , 93 L. Ed. 397 . Petitioner’s contention that he was deprived of counsel was answered, as was his'contention of unlawful search and seizure without warrant, in his former petition, Presley v. Warden, 201 Md. 660 .

See also Daisey v. Warden, 203 Md. 653 , which states that the petitioner has the burden of showing that for want of the opportunity of counsel, “an ingredient of unfairness operated actively in the process that resulted in his confine 662 ment.” Martucci v. Warden, 202 Md. 648 ; Selby v. Warden, 201 Md. 653 . Application denied, with costs.