Maryland case law › Proctor v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Proctor v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

227 Md. 660 (1962) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryProctor was indicted with two others for assault with intent to rob with a deadly weapon, assault with intent to rob, and simple assault. He was convicted on the second count and sentenced to ten years. His conviction was affirmed on direct appeal, where the only issues concerned an extra-judicial identification by the victim. Proctor v. State, 223 Md. 394. In this post-conviction proceeding, he raised for the first time a constitutional claim that the State violated his rights by accepting a guilty plea to simple assault from his codefendant Carle, who received a five-year sentence and testified for the State, thereby giving Carle an opportunity not extended to Proctor. The Court held that the contention was raised too late: failure to make the point at trial or on appeal constitutes a waiver. The Court cited Jordan v. State, 221 Md. 134, and Lipscomb v. Warden, 225 Md. 634, for the wai
Questions presented
  • Whether the applicant's contention that his constitutional rights were violated because the State accepted a plea of guilty of simple assault from a codefendant and the codefendant testified for the State, giving the codefendant an opportunity not extended to the applicant, can be raised for the first time in a post-conviction proceeding.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. The applicant here was indicted, along with two others, of assault with intent to rob with a deadly weapon, assault with 661 intent to rob, and simple assault. He was convicted on the second count, sentenced to ten years, and appealed to this Court. Proctor v. State, 223 Md. 394 .

The only questions raised were concerning an extra-judicial identification made by the victim. The judgment was affirmed. He now seeks to raise for the first time a contention that because the State accepted from Carle, one of his codefendants, a plea of guilty of simple assault, for which he received a sentence of five years, and because Carle testified for the State, the constitutional rights of the applicant were violated. He contends that it was discriminatory, in a constitutional sense, to give Carle an opportunity which was not extended to him.

We think it is too late to raise the point in this proceeding. Failure to make the point at the trial or on appeal constitutes a waiver. Jordan v. State, 221 Md. 134 ; Lipscomb v. Warden, 225 Md. 634 . In so holding, we do not suggest that leniency to a codefendant, or a disparity in sentences, would afford grounds for relief in any event.

Barker v. Warden, 208 Md. 662, 665 . See also Cothorn v. Warden, 221 Md. 581, 582 , and Ellinger v. Warden, 224 Md. 648, 653 . Application denied.