5 Md. App. 199 (1968) · Court of Special Appeals of Maryland
Court of Special Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryJames Reid filed a petition for post-conviction relief under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act in the Criminal Court of Baltimore, alleging ineffective assistance of counsel. Judge Shirley B. Jones denied relief, and Reid applied to the Court of Special Appeals for leave to appeal. The Court of Special Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, denied the application, adopting Judge Jones's reasons. The court took the opportunity to clarify the standard for assessing counsel's competence: rejecting the older 'farce of a trial' test, the court held that the proper inquiry is whether, under all the circumstances of the particular case, the accused was afforded a 'genuine and effective representation.' Applying that standard to the record, the court found that Reid had received adequate and effective representation. The application was therefore denied. The opinion is brief and does not reci
Questions presented
Whether the applicant was afforded adequate and effective representation of counsel, applying the test of whether under all the circumstances of the particular case the accused has been afforded a genuine and effective representation.
Per Curiam. The application of James Reid for leave to appeal from an order of Judge Shirley B. Jones, presiding in the Criminal Court of Baltimore, denying relief prayed in a petition under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act is denied for the reasons set forth by Judge Jones in the memorandum accompanying the order. We note, however, that the test of the inadequacy of counsel is no longer whether the representation was so deficient as to make a farce out of the trial. The rule followed by this Court is that counsel is incompetent when under all the circumstances of the particular case the accused has not been afforded a genuine and effective representation.
Green v. War 200 den, 3 Md. App. 266 . From the record before us, we find that the applicant was afforded adequate and effective representation. Application denied.