Maryland case law › Reynolds v. Lewis

Reynolds v. Lewis

14 Md. 116 (1859) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: DismissedTuck, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal arose from a dispute over the freedom of the appellees, who claimed their liberty under the will of Betty Reynolds. The record transmitted to the Court of Appeals was defective because it failed to include a bill of exceptions, contrary to the agreement of the parties. As a result, the Court of Appeals had nothing before it upon which to revise the judgment of the lower court. The Court therefore dismissed the appeal. In a brief observation, the Court noted that the right of the appellees to their freedom, as appears by the agreements, depends on the construction of the will of Betty Reynolds, which was before the court in the case of Negroes William & Others vs. Reynolds (ante, 109). According to that construction, the judgment in favor of the appellees was properly entered. The Court cited Spencer vs. Dennis, 8 Gill, 314, and Vansant vs. Roberts, 3 Md. Rep., 119, as authori
Questions presented
  • Whether the appeal must be dismissed because the record is defective in not setting out a bill of exceptions, according to the agreement of the parties.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

TticK, J., delivered the opinion of (his court. The record in this case is defective in not setting out a bill of exceptions, according to the agreement of the parties. There is, consequently, nothing before us on which the court can revise the judgment below. The appeal must be dismissed.

We may observe, however, .that the right of the appellees to their freedom, as appears by the agreements, depends on the construction of the will of Betty Reynolds, to be found in the case of Negroes William & Others vs. Reynolds, (ante, 109,) according to which the judgment was properly entered in their favor. Spencer vs. Dennis, 8 Gill, 314 . Vansant vs. Roberts, 3 Md. Rep., 119 . Appeal dismissed.