Maryland case law › Richards v. Jackson

Richards v. Jackson

31 Md. 250 (1869) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedBrent, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case is a short per curiam-style opinion by the Maryland Court of Appeals (Brent, J.) reaffirming its recent decision in Kimberly v. Henderson & Lupton, 29 Md. 512 (1868), and reversing a judgment in favor of a real estate broker. The appellee, a broker employed to sell certain premises, introduced one Byrd to the vendor; Byrd signed an agreement to purchase but never consummated the sale. The broker sued for his commissions, and the trial court instructed the jury in a manner that allowed recovery. On appeal, the Court of Appeals held that a broker employed to sell real estate is not entitled to commissions merely because he produces a person who enters into an agreement to purchase; the broker must produce a person who ultimately becomes the purchaser by actually complying with the agreed terms, unless the failure to consummate is occasioned by the fault of the vendor. The Court r
Questions presented
  • Whether the case of Kimberly v. Henderson & Lupton, 29 Md. 512, should be overruled.
  • Whether a broker employed to sell real estate is entitled to his commissions where the person he introduces enters into an agreement to purchase but fails to consummate the purchase, absent fault of the vendor.
  • Whether the failure to consummate the purchase was occasioned through the fault of the vendor because the vendor did not sell a good title.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Brent, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. ' We have very carefully considered the argument of the counsel for the appellee, in which he urges, with great zeal and ingenuity, that the case of Kimberly vs. Henderson § Lupton, 29 Md., 512 , should be overruled. He has failed to convince us that there is any error in that de 253 cisión. It is fully sustained by the authorities cited in the opinion, and, we think, correctly states the law. (Decided 30th June, 1869.) It is there held that a broker, employed to sell real estate, must produce a person who ultimately becomes a purchaser, before he is entitled to his commissions.

It is not sufficient that he should enter into an agreement to purchase, but he must actually purchase, by complying with the terms agreed upon, unless his failure to do so is occasioned by the fault of the vendor. In this case, as in Kimberly vs. Henderson & Lupton, the person introduced by the broker entered into an agreement to purchase, but he afterwards failed to consummate it. There can be no doubt that the title of the vendor was a valid one, and there is, therefore, no force in the position taken by the appellee, that the failure to consummate the purchase was occasioned through the fault of the vendor, who did not sell a good title. As, therefore, the appellee failed in introducing to Byrd a person who ultimately became the purchaser of the premises, which he had employed him to sell, there was error in the instruction of the Court below, and the judgment must be reversed.

The reversal will be without procedendo, as the record discloses a case in which the appellee, who was plaintiff below, is not entitled to recover. Judgment reversed.