Maryland case law › Rinaldi v. Tana

Rinaldi v. Tana

252 Md. 544 (1969) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedPer Curiam✓ Good law
SummaryThree sisters contracted to sell their identical stock holdings in a family coal and fuel oil corporation to a prospective purchaser for an agreed price. One sister refused to perform, and the purchaser, who had been ready, willing, and able to buy all the sisters' stock, declined to vary the contract and accept only the two tendering sisters' stock for two-thirds of the price. The two tendering sisters sued their brother for maliciously inducing the third sister's breach. The case was tried without a jury before Judge Moore, who found that the brother, not being privileged to do so, purposefully and maliciously, for his own unjustified and selfish reasons, induced his sister not to perform the contract, and was therefore guilty of tortious interference with contract rights under 4 Restatement Torts § 766 and Maryland precedent. The court found him liable for compensatory and punitive da
Questions presented
  • Whether the evidence supported the trial court's finding that the brother maliciously induced his sister to breach the contract to sell stock, thereby committing tortious interference with contract rights.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. Three sisters entered into a contract to sell their identical holdings of stock in a family coal and fuel oil corporation for an agreed price. One sister refused to perform the contract and 545 the prospective purchaser, who had been ready, willing and able to accept and pay for the stock of all the sisters, refused to vary the contract and accept and pay for the stock of the two sisters who tendered it against payment of two-thirds of the purchase price. The two tendering sisters then sued a brother for having maliciously induced the breach of the contract to sell the stock.

Judge Moore, hearing the case without a jury, found that the brother, not being privileged to do so, purposefully and maliciously for his own unjustified and selfish reasons had induced his sister not to perform the contract and therefore was guilty of tortious interference with contract rights, 4 Restatement Torts § 766; Knickerbocker Ice Co. v. Gardiner Dairy Co., 107 Md. 556, 561 , et seq.; Stannard v. McCool, 198 Md. 609 ; Horn v. Seth, 201 Md. 589 ; McGinnis v. Chance, 247 Md. 393, 401 , and liable in compensatory and punitive damages. The testimony and exhibits offer sound support for Judge Moore’s findings of fact, he correctly applied the controlling law, and the damages awarded were appropriate. Judgment affirmed, with costs.