Maryland case law › Roth v. Roth

Roth v. Roth

144 Md. 553 (1924) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedUrner, J.✓ Good law
SummaryA husband separated from his wife filed a bill of complaint seeking to have a lot of ground he owned sold free of his wife's inchoate right of dower. The bill alleged the sale would be advantageous to the parties interested and specifically prayed that a trustee be appointed for the wife's dower interest, that the trustee join with the plaintiff in a sale of the property, and that one-third of the proceeds be invested for the benefit of the plaintiff during his life or so long as he remained the husband of the defendant, to be paid to him discharged of the trust if he survived the defendant or they became absolutely divorced, and to be paid to the defendant in the event of her survivorship as the plaintiff's widow. A demurrer to the bill was sustained. On appeal, the Court of Appeals held that a court of equity has no jurisdiction to decree such a sale. The Code provision relied upon (ar
Questions presented
  • Whether a court of equity has jurisdiction to decree a sale of property owned by the husband free of the wife's inchoate right of dower, under the Code provision (article 16, section 228), where the bill seeks appointment of a trustee for the dower interest and investment of one-third of the proceeds for the husband during his life or until divorce, with payment to the wife if she survives as widow.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

554 Urner, J., delivered the opinion of the Oou-rt. The bill of complaint in this case was filed by a husband who is separated from his wife, and its purpose is to have a lot of ground, of which he is the owner, sold free of his wife’s inchoate right of dower. It is alleged in the bill that such a sale would be advantageous to the parties interested. Tbe specific prayer of the bill is that a decree be passed appointing a trustee for tbe dower interest .of tbe defendant and directing the trustee to join with the plaintiff in a sale of tbe property and to invest one-third of the proceeds for the benefit of tbe plaintiff during bis life, or so long as be continues to be the husband of .the defendant, and to be paid to him discharged of the trust if he survives the defendant, or they become absolutely divorced, and to be paid to the defendant in the event of her survivorship as the plaintiff’s widow.

A demurrer to .the bill was sustained. It is clear that a court of equity has no jurisdiction to decree such a sale as the bill proposed. The 'Code provision (article 16, section 228), by which the proceeding- is sought to be supported, is not available for that purpose. It provides, under certain conditions, for .the sale of property, and the investment of the proceeds, when there exist, under separate ownership, “an estate for life or years,” or “an estate tail, fee simple, conditional, base or qualified fee, or any other particular, limited or conditional estate,” and also “a remainder or remainders, vested or contingent, or an executory devise or devises, or any other interest, vested or contingent in the same land.” An inchoate right of dower is not. within tbe scope of those terms.

It is not an interest which may be the subject of such ownership or disposition .as the statute contemplates. It enures to. tbe wife solely by virtue of the husband’s seisin, and has no* existence independently of his title. It may be extinguished by release, but is not susceptible of being sold or transferred. These principles of tbe law of dower have been repeatedly applied by this Court.

Hill v. Boland, 125 Md. 113 ; Pyle v. Gross, 555 92 Md. 132 ; Duttera v. Babylon, 83 Md. 544 ; Mitchell v. Farrish, 69 Md. 237 ; Reiff v. Horst, 55 Md. 47 . The marital interest which is sought to be made the subject of a judicial sale in this case is one of which the wife cannot be divested without her consent. As Judge McSheery said in Stein v. Stein, 80 Md. 309 , “her status is fixed by the law and she cannot be coerced.” In the ease of Masterman v. Masterman, 129 Md. 167 , upon which the appellant relies, it was said that a decree, under the Code provision we have cited, could bo passed for the sale of property owned by the husband and wife as tenants by the entireties. With such an estate the inchoate dower of a wife could not be classified for the purposes of our present decision.

The order and decree sustaining the demurrer and dismissing the bill of complaint will be affirmed. Order and decree affirmed, with costs.