Maryland case law › Rundle v. Mayor of Baltimore

Rundle v. Mayor of Baltimore

28 Md. 356 (1868) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DismissedAlvey, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from an appeal to the Criminal Court of Baltimore from a determination of the Commissioners for the Opening of Streets. The Criminal Court dismissed the appeal, and the appellant then sought review in the Court of Appeals. The threshold question was whether the Court of Appeals had appellate jurisdiction over the Criminal Court's judgment dismissing the appeal from the Street Commissioners. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Alvey, J., held that no appeal lies to it from such a judgment. The Court reasoned that the right of appeal to the Criminal Court was given by statute, and it was exclusively for that Court to decide whether the appeal was regularly and properly taken. Its judgment on that subject is final and conclusive because no right of appeal from such judgment is given by statute. The Court further explained that in proceedings taken into the Criminal Court
Questions presented
  • Whether this appeal lies from the decision of the Criminal Court of Baltimore dismissing an appeal prosecuted to that Court from the determination of the Commissioners for the Opening of Streets?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Alvey, J., delivered the opinion of this Court. The appeal in this case is taken from a decision of the Criminal Court of Baltimore, dismissing an appeal prosecuted to that Court, from the determination of the Commissioners for the Opening of Streets, and the first question for this Court to decide is, whether this appeal lies? We think it does not. If no appellate power whatever had been conferred On the Criminal Court ‘of Baltimore in such eases, its judgments unwarrantably pronounced in assertion of jurisdiction over the subject, might by appeal be reviewed and reversed in this Court.

But the right of appeal was given to the Criminal Court, and it was exclusively for that Court to decide whether the appeal was regularly and properly taken to it. Its judgment upon the subject is final and conclusive, there being no right of appeal given by statute from such judgment. In regard to proceedings taken into the Criminal Court on appeal from the decision of the Street Commissioners, that Court is clothed only with a special and limited jurisdiction, to be exercised in a particular mode, and not according to the course of the common law; and it has been repeatedly decided that from a judgment rendered in the exercise of special jurisdiction, in the absence of express right given by statute, no appeal will lie to this Court, and whether the judgment be pronounced in the exercise of original jurisdiction, or on appeal from some inferior authority, makes no difference. There being no provision of law authorising an 362 appeal to this Court in such a case as this, the appeal from the decision of the Criminal Court must therefore be dismissed; and the cases of Savage Man’g.

Co. vs. Owings, 3 Gill, 497 ; Swann vs. Mayor, &c. of Cumberland, 8 Gill, 152; Webster vs. Cockey, 9 Gill, 93 ; and Baltimore and Havre de Grace Turnpike Co. vs. Northern Central R. R. Co., 15 Md. Rep., 193 , may be referred to as conclusive authorities upon the question. (Decided 13th March, 1868.) Appeal dismissed.