Maryland case law › Saiontz v. State

Saiontz v. State

183 Md. 13 (1944) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: ReversedBailey, J.✓ Good law
SummaryDavid Saiontz was convicted in the Criminal Court of Baltimore City on two separate indictments, each containing a single count charging multiple violations of the Baltimore City Building Code. In case No. 5189, the indictment charged violations of Paragraphs 4346, 4383, 4387, 4391, 1400, and 2507 with respect to two properties at 1609 and 1611 Eutaw Place, and Saiontz was fined $1,000. In case No. 5190, the indictment charged violations of Paragraphs 4347, 4387, and 4391 with respect to two properties at 1515 and 1517 Linden Avenue, and Saiontz was fined $250. On appeal, the Court of Appeals reversed both judgments. The Court relied on its reasoning in the companion case Kirsner v. State, 183 Md. 1, 36 A.2d 538, which had considered similar indictments. The Court further held that the indictments were duplicitous for an additional reason: violations of the Building Code with respect to
Questions presented
  • Whether the indictments were duplicitous because they charged violations of the Building Code with respect to two separate and distinct properties in the same count.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

14 Bailey, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This case was argued with the case of Kirsner v. State, 183 Md. 1 , 36 A. 2d 538 . There are two appeals in the record. The first appeal is from a judgment of the Criminal Court of Baltimore City, entered on April 8, 1943, in case No. 5189, sentencing the defendant, David Saiontz, appellant in this court, to pay a fine of §1,000.

The second appeal is from a judgment of the same court, entered on the same day, in case No. 5190, whereby the appellant was sentenced to a fine of §250. The indictment in each case contains a single count, charging multiple violations of the Baltimore City Building Code. The indictments are similar to the indictments considered by us in Kirsner v. State, supra. The indictment in case No. 5189 charges violations of Paragraphs 4346, 4383, 4387, 4391, 1400 and 2507 of the Building Code.

The paragraphs alleged to have been violated in case No. 5190 are 4347, 4387, and 4391. For the reasons stafed in our opinion in the case of Kirsner v. State, supra, the judgments must be reversed. We.feel, however, that in this case the indictments are duplicitous for an additional reason. In case No. 5189, the violations are charged with respect to two properties at 1609 and 1611 Eutaw Place, and in case No. 5190, at 1515 and 1517 Linden Avenue.

Violations of the Building Code with respect to two separate and distinct properties cannot be charged in the same count of the indictment. Judgments in both cases reversed.