Maryland case law › Sellers v. Zimmerman

Sellers v. Zimmerman

18 Md. 255 (1862) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedCochran, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis was an action of trespass for assault and battery. The appellees (defendants below) pleaded not guilty and, through Henry Zimmerman, also pleaded son assault demesne (self-defense). The appellant (plaintiff below) replied de injuria to the son assault demesne plea, but no formal issue was joined on that replication. At trial, after the case was closed and argued to the jury, the appellant sought to offer additional evidence; the trial court refused, relying on a rule of court set out in the bill of exceptions. The trial court also granted the appellees' prayer instructing the jury on the pleadings and evidence. The prayer assumed there was no evidence that the assault was committed on the day laid in the declaration, and on that assumption treated the appellees as having committed themselves on like issues and evidence. On appeal, the Court of Appeals (Cochran, J.) held that the ref
Questions presented
  • Whether the refusal of the court below to permit the appellant to offer evidence after the case was closed and argued before the jury affords reason for a reversal of the judgment.
  • Whether the prayer asking an instruction on the pleadings and evidence ought to have been granted.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Cochran, J., delivered the opinion of this court. The refusal of the court below to permit the appellant to 259 offer evidence after the case was closed and argued before the jury, affords no reason for a reversal of this judgment, as that refusal was fully justified by the rule of the court, presented in the bill of exceptions. We think, however, that the prayer, asking an instruction on the pleadings and evidence, ought not to have been granted. As it was designed to obtain a common and like advantage for the appellees, they will not, in view of its purpose, be considered as standing on different defences in the pleadings, nor as wrong-doers in different degrees, upon the evidence.

The instruction was asked upon the assumption in the prayer, that there was no evidence that the assault alleged was committed on the day laid in the declaration, and, upon that assumption, they must be considered as having committed themselves, on like issues, and evidence to the law involved in the prayer. (Decided February 26th, 1862.) “ In looking to the proceedings, we find that the appellees have taken like defences upon .their pleas of not guilty, upon which issues were joined, and we think that the prayer, as it refers to the pleadings, should be considered as involving these issues only, especially as no formal issue was joined on the appellants replication, de injuria, to the plea of son assault demesne, pleaded by Henry Zimmerman. It is well settled, that in an issue joined on a plea of not guilty in an action like this, proof of the commission of a trespass on the day laid in the declaration, is not material, and that evidence of its commission on any day before suit brought, is sufficient. As the granting of the prayer was erroneous for this reason, we must reverse the judgment.

Judgment reversed, and procedendo awarded.