Maryland case law › Shefton v. Warden of the Maryland Penitentiary

Shefton v. Warden of the Maryland Penitentiary

234 Md. 627 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryShefton filed a petition for post conviction relief on August 8, 1963, alleging five grounds: (1) arrest without a warrant; (2) being held incommunicado; (3) denial of the right to hire an attorney after arrest; (4) arraignment without counsel; and (5) improper identification. An amended petition added a sixth ground: (6) that his guilty plea was induced by an involuntary confession obtained through threats and coercion by police officers. The lower court denied relief, and Shefton sought leave to appeal. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, denied the application as to contentions (2) through (6) for the reasons assigned by the lower court. As to contention (1), the Court held that the mere fact of an illegal arrest affords no ground for post conviction relief, though an illegal arrest plus something obtained through it may afford such ground. Because Shefton did not allege an
Questions presented
  • Whether the mere fact that an arrest was illegal affords a ground for post conviction relief.
  • Whether being held incommunicado affords a ground for post conviction relief.
  • Whether denial of the right to hire an attorney after arrest affords a ground for post conviction relief.
  • Whether arraignment without counsel affords a ground for post conviction relief.
  • Whether improper identification affords a ground for post conviction relief.
  • Whether a guilty plea induced by an involuntary confession obtained through threats and coercion by police officers affords a ground for post conviction relief.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. On August 8, 1963, the applicant filed a petition for post conviction relief, alleging: (1) he was arrested without a warrant; (2) he was held incommunicado; (3) he was denied the right to hire an attorney after his arrest; (4) he was arraigned without counsel; and (5) he was improperly identified. An amended petition was later filed alleging as an additional ground for relief that (6) his plea of guilty was induced by his having made a confession involuntarily as a result of threats and coercion by police officers. For the reasons assigned by the lower court, the application 628 for leave to appeal will be denied as to contentions (2) through (6).

As to contention (1), the mere fact that an arrest was illegal affords no ground for post conviction relief, though an illegal arrest plus something obtained through it may afford such ground. Here there is no allegation of any product of the illegal arrest. Young v. Warden, 233 Md. 596 , 195 A. 2d 713 ; Dailey v. State, 234 Md. 325 , 199 A. 2d 211 . Application denied.