Maryland case law › Shields v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

Shields v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

212 Md. 655 (1966) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedHammond✓ Good law
SummaryNathaniel Shields, serving a five-year sentence in the Maryland House of Correction, filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County, which was denied by Judge Michael Paul Smith. Shields sought leave to appeal, raising three grounds for relief. First, he contended that he was jointly tried with his brother despite having informed his counsel that he wished to be tried separately. The Court of Appeals held that the denial of a severance goes to the regularity of the proceedings and is reviewable, if at all, on appeal and not on habeas corpus, citing Barker v. Warden, 208 Md. 662. Second, Shields argued that his court-appointed counsel was incompetent and gave improper advice. He stated that he complained about his counsel but did not specify to whom. The Court held that under these circumstances, incompetence of counsel is not a ground for habeas co
Questions presented
  • Whether the denial of a severance, where the petitioner was jointly tried with his brother despite informing counsel he wished to be tried separately, is a ground for habeas corpus relief.
  • Whether incompetence of court-appointed counsel, where the petitioner complained but did not specify to whom, and did not allege fraud, bad faith, or collusion with any State official, is a ground for habeas corpus relief.
  • Whether alleged errors in the admission of evidence, specifically the admission of the petitioner's record, are reviewable on habeas corpus.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Hammond, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Nathaniel Shields, serving a sentence of five years in the House óf Correction, asked Judge Michael Paul Smith of the Circuit Court for Baltimore County for the writ of habeas corpus and was turned down. He seeks leave to appeal from that denial, basing his right to relief on three grounds. His first contention is that he was jointly tried with his brother in spite of the fact that he had informed his counsel that he wished to be tried separately.

He does not allege that he made this request to the court and, assuming that he did, the denial of a severance goes to the regularity of the proceedings and is reviewable, if at all, on appeal and not on habeas corpus. Barker v. Warden, 208 Md. 662 . Secondly, he contends that his court-appointed counsel was incompetent and gave him improper advice. He states that he did complain about his counsel, but he does not say, nor does the record show, to whom the complaint was made.

Under these circumstances, we have repeatedly refused to recognize the contention of incompetence of counsel as a ground for the issuance of the writ of habeas corpus, at least where the pe 657 titioner fails to allege fraud, bad faith or collusion with any official of the State. Faught v. Warden, 205 Md. 639 ; Wagner v. Warden, 205 Md. 648 . The petitioner’s final contention is that the trial court was biased and prejudiced by the admission of his record, although he states that he is not attempting to retry the question of his guilt or innocence. Alleged errors in the admission of evidence in the trial court are reviewable on appeal but not on habeas corpus.

Thompson v. Warden, 209 Md. 628 ; Bergen v. Warden, 208 Md. 677 ; Stokes v. Warden, 205 Md. 629 . Application denied, with costs.