Maryland case law › Silverberg v. Silverberg

Silverberg v. Silverberg

151 Md. 152 (1926) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: ReversedBoot, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case is a follow-up to the divorce litigation between Eose Silverberg and her husband, which had been decided by this Court in Silverberg v. Silverberg, 148 Md. 682. In that prior appeal, the Court had reduced the wife's counsel fee from $2,000 to $1,000, noting the unnecessary expense imposed on the husband. After the cross-appeals were decided, the wife petitioned the trial court for an additional fee to compensate her counsel for services rendered on appeal. The trial judge denied the petition, stating that he was acting on the opinion of the Court of Appeals. The wife appealed that denial. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Chief Judge Bond, held that the prior reduction of the fee did not cover appellate services and was not intended to deny additional compensation for those services. The Court recognized the need to protect a husband from groundless or excessive litigation
Questions presented
  • Whether the trial court erred in refusing to require the husband to pay an additional counsel fee for the wife's services on appeal, where the prior allowance did not cover appellate services and the Court of Appeals had not intended to deny additional compensation for those services.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Boot, C. J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This case may be disposed of briefly. Eose Silverberg now appeals from the refusal of the trial court to require her husband to pay her a fee for the services of her counsel in connection with their cross-appeals, on their respective bills for divorce, heard and decided in this Court. Silverberg v. Silverberg, 148 Md. 682 .

The trial judge denied the application for the fee, and dismissed the wife’s petition, saying, “On the opinion of the Court of Appeals, I will dismiss the petition in this case.” In the decision on the cross-appeals, this Court, in the opinion, adverted to the unnecessary burden of expense imposed upon the husband in the taking of testimony and in the preparation of the record on appeal, and reduced the amount to be paid to the wife for her counsel fee from $2,000, which had been allowed below, to $1,000. That allowance did not cover a payment for services on appeal, and it was not the intention of the court to deny the right to any additional compensation, to coyer those services. On the contrary, it is the opinion of the court that some additional compensation may still be properly allowed. While the Court considers that it is required to give some protection to a 154 husband from groundless or excessive expense in litigation by a wife, at the same time, of course, it must secure to a wife an opportunity to have her case fully presented and adjudicated.

And while -in this case the expense put upon the husband was excessive, we have concluded, after weighing all conflicting considerations, that there should be an additional allowance for counsel fee of $250. . Order reversed, and cause remanded for an' order to be passed in accordance ivith this opinion, ivith costs to the appellant.