Maryland case law › Simmons v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Simmons v. Director of Patuxent Institution

229 Md. 638 (1962) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Remanded✓ Good law
SummaryIn this application for leave to appeal from an order of the lower court recommitting the applicant to the Patuxent Institution for further study and treatment, the record showed that the lower court declined to make a determination of the only issue presented—whether the applicant was a defective delinquent at the time of the hearing. The court explained that it could not decide which of the expert witnesses was right as to whether the applicant 'should be released into society,' and therefore recommitted him without making a finding on defective delinquency. The Court of Appeals held that this was error: the lower court was required to decide the only issue presented, i.e., whether the applicant was a defective delinquent at the time of the hearing. Because the court failed to make that determination, the proceeding was remanded for further proceedings so that the lower court could dec
Questions presented
  • Whether the lower court erred in recommitting the applicant to the Patuxent Institution for further study and treatment without making a finding as to whether or not he was a defective delinquent, where the court declined to determine the only issue presented because it could not decide which of the expert witnesses was right as to whether the applicant should be released into society.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. In this application for leave to appeal from the order of the lower court recommitting the applicant to the Patuxent Institution for further study and treatment without making a finding as to whether or not he was a defective delinquent, the record shows that the court, because it could not decide which of the expert witnesses was right as to whether or not the applicant “should be released into society,” declined to make a determination of the only issue presented. This proceeding must therefore be remanded for further proceedings to the end that the lower court may decide whether or not the applicant was a defective delinquent at the time of the hearing. Application for leave to appeal granted and petition remanded for further proceedings.