Maryland case law › Smith v. State

Smith v. State

143 Md. 541 (1923) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedThomas, J.✓ Good law
SummaryTwo appeals were docketed in this Court from judgments of the court below, one by Harry W. White (No. 24 Appeals, April Term) and one by Luther Smith, Seth Peterson, Hay Porter (Prater), and Ernest B. Neely (No. 25 Appeals, same term), both appeals being in one record. In No. 25, a motion was filed to dismiss the appeal on the ground that the appeal was not taken within thirty days from the entry of the judgments. The Court, referring to its reasoning in No. 24, held that the docket entries showed an appeal on behalf of all of the defendants was noted on the day the judgments were entered. The Court further held that a further written order for appeal and affidavit were not necessary in order to accomplish their appeal, and that the only purpose and effect of an affidavit in such cases is to stay the execution of the sentence, citing Code, art. 5, sec. 80. Accordingly, the motion to dism
Questions presented
  • Whether the appeal in No. 25 should be dismissed on the ground that the appeal was not taken within thirty days from the entry of the judgments.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

542 Thomas, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. In this Court two appeals were docketed from the judgments of tire court below, one by Harry W. White or Harold W. White, as No. 24 Appeals of the April Term, and one by Luther Smith, S'eth Pteterson, Hay Porter (Prater) and Ernest B. Neely, as No. 25 Appeals of the same term, both appeals being in one record. In this case, No. 25 Appeals, a motion has been filed to dismiss the appeal on the ground that the appeal was not taken within thirty days from the entry of the judgments. But, as we have said in No. 24, the docket entries show t-hat-an appeal on behalf of all of the defendants was noted on the day the judgments were entered.

A further written order for appeal and affidavit were not necessary in order to accomplish their appeal, and the only purpose and effect of an affidavit in such cases is to stay the execution of the sentence. Code, art. 5, sec. 80. The motion to dismiss the appeal must therefore be overruled, and for the reasons we have stated in No. 24, the judgments appealed from will be affirmed. Judgments affirmed, with costs.