Maryland case law › Snyder v. Glusing

Snyder v. Glusing

307 Md. 548 (1986) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Reversed✓ Good law
SummaryThis contested election case arose from the September 9, 1986, primary elections and involved the Republican Party's nomination of a candidate for State Senator from the Eighth Legislative District. The appellant filed a petition to void the election under Md.Code (1957, 1983 Repl. Vol., 1985 Cum.Supp.), Art. 33, §§ 19-1 through 19-5. The Circuit Court for Baltimore County, acting pursuant to Maryland Rule 2-519, granted the appellees' motions for judgment at the close of the appellant's evidence and dismissed the petition. On direct appeal under § 19-4(3)(i), the Court of Appeals held that the appellant presented at least a prima facie case that the appellees violated Art. 33, § 26-16(a)(7) by causing a sample ballot to be distributed that did not clearly indicate the name of the candidate or committee responsible for the literature. The Court further held that the circuit court applied
Questions presented
  • Whether the appellant presented at least a prima facie case that the appellees violated Art. 33, § 26-16(a)(7) by causing a sample ballot to be distributed which did not clearly indicate the name of the candidate or committee responsible for the literature.
  • Whether the circuit court applied an incorrect standard in evaluating the appellant's proof by concluding that the violation had not 'affected the outcome of the election' rather than applying the standard under Art. 33, § 19-5(1).
  • Whether the appellant's proof, including the permissible inferences therefrom most favorable to the appellant, was legally sufficient to permit a fact finder to determine that the violation might have changed the outcome of the election.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER CURIAM: This contested election case, growing out of the September 9, 1986, primary elections, involves the nomination by 550 the Republican Party of a candidate for State Senator from the Eighth Legislative District. Appellant filed a petition to void that election pursuant to Md.Code (1957, 1983 Repl. Vol., 1985 Cum.Supp.), Art. 33, §§ 19-1 through 19-5. The Circuit Court for Baltimore County, acting pursuant to Maryland Rule 2-519, granted motions for judgment made by the appellees at the close of the evidence offered by the appellant and dismissed the petition.

Appeal is directly to this Court under § 19—4(3)(i). On the record before us we conclude that the appellant presented at least a prima facie case that the appellees had violated Art. 33, § 26-16(a)(7) by causing a sample ballot to be distributed which did not clearly indicate the name of the candidate or committee responsible for the literature. We further conclude that the circuit court applied an incorrect standard in evaluating the appellant’s proof in that the circuit court concluded that the above-described violation had not “affected the outcome of the election,” whereas under Art. 33, § 19-5(1) the standard is whether the court can find, “based upon clear and convincing evidence, that the act or omission involved materially affected the rights of interested parties or the purity of the. election process and [mjight have changed the outcome of an election already held[.]” (Emphasis added.) Finally, we conclude that the appellant’s proof, including the permissible inferences therefrom most favorable to the appellant, was legally sufficient to permit a fact finder to determine that the violation might have changed the outcome of the election. Mandate to issue forthwith.

JUDGMENT OF THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR BALTIMORE COUNTY REVERSED AND CASE REMANDED TO THAT COURT FOR FURTHER PROCEEDINGS CONSISTENT WITH THIS OPINION. COSTS TO BE PAID BY THE APPELLEES.