Maryland case law › Solf v. State

Solf v. State

227 Md. 192 (1961) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryLena Katherine Solf was convicted, along with her son and an acquaintance, of armed robbery. At trial, the victim positively identified Solf in open court. Over defense objection, the State was also permitted to introduce evidence that the victim had previously identified Solf from a photograph of her mingled among some fifty other photographs shown to him by police. On appeal, Solf contended that because the in-court identification was sufficient, the extrajudicial photographic identification was unnecessary and its admission constituted reversible error. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, rejected this contention. The Court held that it was not error to admit evidence of a prior extrajudicial identification of the accused, citing Proctor v. State, Bulluck v. State, Judy v. State, and Basoff v. State. The Court further held that the additional proof of identity was not preju
Questions presented
  • Whether the admission of an extrajudicial identification of the accused, where the witness also made a positive in-court identification, constitutes reversible error because the extrajudicial identification was not necessary to establish identification.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. The appellant (Lena Katherine Solf) was convicted, with her son and an acquaintance, of armed robbery. At the trial, the victim, who positively identified her in open court, was allowed to testify over objection that he had previously identified the accused from a picture of her mingled with some fifty other photographs shown him by the police. No effort was made to show (on a motion for a mistrial or otherwise) that the appellant had been prejudiced by the introduction of the cumulative evidence.

The claim on this appeal is that since the extrajudicial identification was not necessary to establish identification, the admission thereof was reversible error. The contention is without merit. Clearly, it was not error to admit into evidence the extrajudicial identification of the accused. Proctor v. State, 223 Md. 394 ; Bulluck v. State, 219 Md. 67 ; Judy v. State, 218 Md. 168 ; Basoff v. State, 208 Md. 643 .

Nor was the additional proof of identity prejudicial under the circumstances. See Cook v. State, 225 Md. 603 ; Contee v. State, 223 Md. 575 ; Lusby v. State, 217 Md. 191 . Judgment affirmed.