Maryland case law › Stansbury v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Stansbury v. Director of Patuxent Institution

243 Md. 733 (1966) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryStansbury applied for leave to appeal from an order of the Criminal Court of Baltimore finding that he remained a Defective Delinquent. He raised two contentions: (1) that the testimony of Dr. Boslow, the Director of Patuxent Institution, was based in part on the conclusions of other staff members at Patuxent, and (2) that because he was a first offender convicted of a misdemeanor, he did not fit the statutory definition of a defective delinquent. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, rejected both contentions. As to the first, the Court noted that several prior decisions had held that the Director of Patuxent may base his opinion on the reports of his staff members, citing Alt v. Director, 240 Md. 262 (1965), and Murel v. Director, 240 Md. 258 (1965). Accordingly, the first contention was without merit. As to the second, the Court held that because the applicant had been convic
Questions presented
  • Whether the testimony of Dr. Boslow was improperly based in part on conclusions of other staff members at Patuxent.
  • Whether, since applicant is a first offender convicted of a misdemeanor, he does not fit the statutory definition of defective delinquent.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. In his application for leave to appeal from an order of the Criminal Court of Baltimore finding that applicant is still a Defective Delinquent, he raises two basic contentions: 1) That the testimony of Dr. Boslow was based in part on conclusions of other staff members at Patuxent and, 2) That since applicant is a first offender convicted of a misdemeanor he does not fit the statutory definition of defective delinquent. As is pointed out in the memorandum submitted by the Attorney General, several cases have held that the Director of Patuxent may base his opinion on the reports of his staff members ; therefore, applicant’s first contention is without merit. Alt v. Director, 240 Md. 262 (1965); Murel v. Director, 240 Md. 258 (1965).

Applicant’s second contention is likewise without merit since he was convicted of a misdemeanor punishable by commitment in the penitentiary (automobile larceny) and therefore fits the statutory definition of a defective delinquent. For these reasons, his application for leave to appeal must be denied. Application denied.