Maryland case law › State ex rel. Blankenship v. Palmer

State ex rel. Blankenship v. Palmer

240 Md. 728 (1965) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryAfter an adverse jury verdict in the Circuit Court for Prince George's County, the equitable plaintiff—the mother of an eight-year-old daughter killed by an automobile while roller skating—appealed, presenting only two questions: (1) whether the trial judge erred in refusing plaintiff's instruction No. 3, and (2) whether he committed prejudicial error in not instructing the jury sua sponte on the doctrine of last clear chance. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, affirmed. As to the first question, the requested instruction began with the assertion that 'there being no evidence in this case of want of due care on the part of Doris Blankenship, the decedent child, for own safety,' which the Court held was a false postulate because there was evidence in the case which, if believed by the jury, would have justified a finding of contributory negligence; moreover, the court's charge
Questions presented
  • Did the trial judge err in refusing plaintiff's instruction No. 3?
  • Did he commit prejudicial error in not instructing, sua sponte, the jury on the doctrine of last clear chance?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Pjjr Curiam. After an adverse jury verdict rendered in the Circuit Court for Prince George’s County, the equitable plaintiff, a mother of an eight-year-old daughter who was killed by an automobile while roller skating, appealed. Only two questions are presented: (1), Did the trial judge err in refusing plaintiff’s instruction No. 3?; and (2), Did he commit prejudicial error in not instructing, sua sponte, the jury on the doctrine of last clear chance ? No benefit will result if we set forth plaintiff’s requested instruction No. 3 in full.

It begins, “The Court instructs the jury that there being no evidence in this case of want of due care on the part of Doris Blankenship, the decedent child, for own safety, * * (Italics ours.) This is a false postulate in the prayer; there was evidence in the case which, if believed by the jury, would have justified a finding of contributory negligence. Moreover, an examination of the court’s charge relative to contributory negligence discloses it to be adequate. In regard to the second question, apart from the fact that there was no request for an instruction relative to last clear chance or objection to its omission from the charge, Maryland Rule 554, the factual situation, as developed in the trial, did not justify such an instruction. Judgment affirmed; appellant to pay the costs.