Maryland case law › State ex rel. Mentzer v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

State ex rel. Mentzer v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

191 Md. 744 (1948) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryPetitioner Mentzer sought leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus by Judge Michael J. Manley of the Supreme Bench of Baltimore. He had been convicted in the Circuit Court for Frederick County of assault and battery and sentenced to five years in the Maryland House of Correction. In his habeas petition, Mentzer raised three complaints: (1) that he was not afforded a preliminary hearing; (2) that he was denied the opportunity to summons witnesses; and (3) that he was denied the opportunity to take the stand in his own defense. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, addressed each contention. As to the absence of a preliminary hearing, the Court held that a preliminary hearing is not necessary for the obtention of a valid indictment. As to the remaining complaints regarding witnesses and his own testimony, the Court noted that petitioner was represented by counsel
Questions presented
  • Whether the absence of a preliminary hearing invalidates an indictment?
  • Whether habeas corpus may be used as a substitute for appeal to challenge the denial of the opportunity to summons witnesses and to take the stand in one's own defense?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER CURIAM. Petitioner applies for leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus by Judge Michael J. Manley of the Supreme Bench of Baltimore. He was convicted in the Circuit Court for Frederick County of assault and battery and sentenced to five years in the Maryland House of Correction. Petitioner complains of not having a preliminary hearing.

This is not necessary for the obtention of a valid indictment. He also states he was denied the opportunity to summons witnesses and to take the stand in his own defense. Petitioner was represented by counsel at his trial. Habeas corpus cannot be made a sustitute for appeal.

Application denied, without costs.