Maryland case law › State v. Carter

State v. Carter

49 Md. 8 (1878) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Dismissed✓ Good law
SummaryThe State, through a private attorney employed by private parties to assist the State's Attorney, sought to appeal from a criminal judgment in the Circuit Court under the Act of 1872, ch. 316. That statute authorizes the party accused, or the State's Attorney in behalf of the State of Maryland, to tender a bill of exceptions, and permits the party tendering such bill to appeal. The private attorney had participated in the trial with the consent of the State's Attorney and leave of court, but took the appeal without the consent or co-operation of the State's Attorney. The appellee moved to dismiss the appeal on the ground that the appeal was not taken by the person authorized by law. Neither the State's Attorney nor the Attorney-General, whose constitutional duty it is to represent the State in this Court, opposed the motion. The Court of Appeals held that under the Act of 1872, the only
Questions presented
  • Whether an appeal in the name and behalf of the State may be taken by a private attorney employed by private parties to assist the State's Attorney, where the appeal is taken without the consent or co-operation of the State's Attorney.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

By the Court : The Act of 1872, ch. 316, authorizes “ the party accused, or the State’s Attorney in behalf of the Stale of Maryland, to tender to the Court a bill.of exceptions, which shall be signed and sealed by the Court, as is now practiced within this State in civil cases, and the party tendering such bill of exceptions may appeal, &c.” Under this law, the only person authorized to take an appeal in the name and behalf of the State, is the State’s Attorney. In this case it appears from the record, that the appeal was taken and is now prosecuted by an attorney, who was employed by private parties to assist the State’s Attorney, and by his consent with the leave of the Court, participated with him in the trial of the case in the Circuit Court; and who has taken the appeal without the consent or co-operation of the State’s Attorney. For this reason the appellee has moved that the appeal be dismissed. The motion is not opposed either by the 10 State’s Attorney, .or by the Attorney-General, whose duty it is to represent the State in this Court.

(Constitution, Art. 5, sec. 3.) Under these circumstances the motion must prevail and the appeal will he dismissed. (Decided 15th May, 1878.) Appeal dismissed.