Maryland case law › State v. Dunnington

State v. Dunnington

12 Md. 340 (1858) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe State of Maryland brought an action against Dunnington (and others) on a collector's bond, and the defendants demurred to the declaration. The circuit court sustained the demurrer and entered judgment for the defendants; the State appealed. On appeal, the Court of Appeals (Le Grand, C.J.) affirmed. The Court held that the declaration failed to state a cause of action because it did not clearly allege whether any bond was given at all or only an insufficient bond, making the pleading ambiguous and defective. More fundamentally, the Court held that the commissioners charged with taking or approving the collector's bond exercised a duty requiring 'the exercise of judgment and discretion' — a judicial, not ministerial, function — and that a mere error in judgment does not give the State a right of action. Because the declaration contained no allegation that the commissioners acted corrup
Questions presented
  • Whether the court properly sustained the demurrer to the declaration.
  • Whether the duty imposed upon the commissioners was ministerial or one requiring the exercise of judgment and discretion, such that a mere error in judgment gives the State a right of action.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. We think the court properly sustained the demurrer to the declaration, and affirm their judgment. It does not clearly appear from the nar whether or not any bond was given by the collector, it is doubtful whether the allegation was intended to deny that any bond at. all was given, or only that an insiifficient one was given. Without going into an examination of the authorities bearing on the question presented by the demurrer, we consider it sufficient for the purposes of this case to refer to the decision at this term in the case of Green vs. Purnell, Comptroller of the Treasury, (ante 329.) The principle there decided covers this case.

The duty imposed upo* 348 the commissioners, was one requiring of them “the exercise of judgment and discretion.” It was judicial and not ministerial. A mere error in judgment does not give to the State a right of action. The nar does not contain any allegation that the commissioners acted corruptly. (Decided July 22nd, 1858.) Judgment affirmed.