Maryland case law › State v. Gilbert

State v. Gilbert

9 Md. App. 118 (1970) · Maryland Court of Special Appeals
Maryland Court of Special AppealsDisposition: Dismissed✓ Good law
SummaryJanet Gilbert was indicted jointly with James Gilbert on four counts of a ten-count indictment. The State appealed from an order of the trial court granting Gilbert's motion to dismiss three of the counts. Gilbert moved to dismiss the State's appeal. The Court of Special Appeals granted the motion to dismiss the appeal, holding that under State v. Gregg, 163 Md. 353, 163 A. 119, an appeal is premature where other counts in the indictment remain open after a motion to dismiss has been granted as to some counts. The court also cited State v. Gibson, 4 Md. App. 236, 242 A.2d 575, note 6, for the same proposition. The court noted that if it had considered the appeal on the merits, it would have affirmed the trial court's action for the reasons fully set out in State v. Michael, 2 Md. App. 750, 237 A.2d 782, stating that an indictment, or count thereof, which is invalid on its face cannot be
Questions presented
  • Whether the State's appeal is premature where other counts in the indictment remained open after a motion to dismiss had been granted as to some of the counts.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. Janet Gilbert, the appellee, was indicted, jointly with 119 one James Gilbert, on four counts of a ten count indictment. The State appeals from an order of the trial court granting a motion to dismiss three of the counts. She moves to dismiss the appeal and we grant the motion.

State v. Gregg, 163 Md. 353 , 163 A. 119 held an appeal premature where other counts in the indictment remained open after a motion to dismiss had been granted as to some of the counts. See also State v. Gibson, 4 Md. App. 236 , 242 A. 2d 575, note 6 . If we had considered the appeal on the merits we would have affirmed the action of the trial court for the reasons fully set out in State v. Michael, 2 Md. App. 750 , 237 A. 2d 782 . An indictment, or count thereof, which is invalid on its face cannot be saved by the offer of testimony to support allegations not contained therein.

Appeal dismissed. Costs to be paid by the County Council of Baltimore County. Mandate to issue forthwith.