Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: OtherBell, J. (dissenting)⚠ Negative treatment (1)
SummaryThis opinion is a dissenting opinion by Judge Bell, joined by Judge Eldridge, in State v. Woodland, 337 Md. 519 (1995). The dissent addresses whether a conviction for possession of controlled dangerous substances with intent to distribute is admissible for impeachment purposes under Maryland Rule 1-502. The majority had held such a conviction admissible, relying on State v. Giddens, 335 Md. 205, 642 A.2d 870 (1994), which permitted impeachment by a conviction for distribution of a controlled dangerous substance. The dissent states that if the majority's foundation were sound—i.e., if a distribution conviction is admissible for impeachment—then it would logically follow that a possession with intent to distribute conviction is also admissible. However, the dissent disagrees with the majority's foundational premise, expressly adopting the reasoning of the dissenting opinion in Giddens, 335
Questions presented
Whether a conviction for possession of controlled dangerous substances with intent to distribute is admissible for impeachment purposes pursuant to Maryland Rule 1-502.
BELL, Judge, dissenting. If the foundation on which the majority builds were sound, then the result it reaches would be correct; if a conviction for distribution of a controlled dangerous substance is admissible for impeachment purposes, pursuant to Maryland Rule 1-502, see State v. Giddens, 335 Md. 205 , 642 A.2d 870 (1994), then it logically would follow that a conviction for possession of controlled dangerous substances with intent to distribute is also admissible for that purpose. For the reasons set forth in the dissenting opinion in Giddens, 335 Md. at 223 , 642 A.2d at 878-79 , I do not believe the majority’s foundation is sound. I would affirm the judgment of the Court of Special Appeals.
ELDRIDGE, J., joins in the views herein expressed.