Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis case involved a pleading dispute in which the defendant's rejoinder was challenged by demurrer. The plaintiff demurred to the rejoinder, arguing that it was double. The court considered whether the rejoinder was double and whether the demurrer was sufficient to raise the objection. The court held that the rejoinder was not double, and even if it were, the demurrer was a general demurrer and therefore insufficient to support the objection. The court explained that a demurrer must be to one single, certain, material point, but that point need not consist of a single fact. The court also noted that when a demurrer is argued before trial of the issue, the court will give leave to amend. The court further stated that duplicity in pleading must be taken advantage of by special demurrer, and it is not sufficient to demur 'quia duplex et caret forma'; the pleader must lay a finger on the ve
Questions presented
Whether the rejoinder was double.
Whether the demurrer was sufficient to support the objection of duplicity.
The Court were of opinion that the rejoinder was not double, and even if it was, the demurrer was a general demurrer, and, consequently, not sufficient to support the objection. It must be one single, certain, material point, but it is not necessary that this single point should consist of a single fact. Burr. 320. When the demurrer is argued before a trial of the issue, the court will give leave to amend.
Burr. 322. Duplicity in pleading must be taken advantage of by special demurrer, and it is not sufficient to demur quia duplex et caret forma, but you must lay your finger on the very point that is so. 4 Bac. Abr. 119. Where an immaterial fact is put in issue it is only surplusage, and does not make the plea double.
The demurrer was overruled, and judgment given for the defendant.