Maryland case law › Sturgis v. Warden of the Maryland Penitentiary

Sturgis v. Warden of the Maryland Penitentiary

241 Md. 728 (1966) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryPer curiam denial of an application for leave to appeal from the denial of post conviction relief by Judge Mace. The applicant, convicted of a crime and confined in the Maryland Penitentiary, applied for leave to appeal on 4 July 1965 without stating reasons as required by Maryland Rule BK 46 b, but later filed letters dated 11 July and 26 August 1965 to the Clerk of this Court contradicting trial and post conviction testimony and raising new matters. The Court assumed without deciding that the applicant sufficiently complied with Rule BK 46 b, and found that all of his contentions except the ninth were adequately and properly dealt with by Judge Mace. The ninth contention—that he did not commit the crime—was not subject to review in a post conviction hearing under Nance v. State, 239 Md. 404, 211 A. 2d 739 (1965). In his 11 July letter, the applicant raised for the first time the conten
Questions presented
  • Whether the applicant sufficiently complied with Maryland Rule BK 46 b.
  • Whether the applicant's contention that he did not commit the crime is subject to review in a post conviction hearing.
  • Whether the applicant's contention that his car was illegally searched, raised for the first time in his letter of 11 July, is properly before the Court.
  • Whether the applicant is entitled to relief under Schowgurow v. State.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. On 4 July 1965 the applicant applied for leave to appeal from a denial of post conviction relief by Judge Mace without stating his reasons why the court’s order should be modified or reversed as required by Maryland Rule BK 46 b. Applicant, however, did file letters dated 11 July and 26 August 1965, both addressed to the Clerk of this Court, in which he contradicted matters testified to at his trial and at the post conviction hearing and in addition raised matters not asserted in the court below. Assuming, without deciding, that applicant has sufficiently complied with Maryland Rule BK 46 b, we find that all, except the ninth, of his contentions were adequately and properly dealt with by Judge Mace.

Applicant’s ninth contention is that he did not commit the crime. Although Judge Mace did not dispose of this, it is clear that the question of guilt is not subject to review in a post conviction hearing. Nance v. State, 239 Md. 404 , 211 A. 2d 739 (1965). In his letter of 11 July applicant presents for the first time the contention that his car was illegally searched.

Not having 730 been raised below, this contention is not properly before us. Roe v. Director, 240 Md. 717 (1965). We observe in passing, however, that there is no allegation that there was an illegal seizure of any evidence from the car, nor that any such evidence was used against the applicant. Therefore, applicant states no ground for relief.

Forrester v. Warden, 233 Md. 620 , 195 A. 2d 693 (1963). In a letter dated 20 January 1966 applicant requests relief under Schowgurow v. State, 240 Md. 121 , 213 A. 2d 475 (1965). Applicant’s conviction became final well before Schowgurow so he does not come within the ambit of that case. Husk v. Warden, 240 Md. 353 , 214 A. 2d 139 (1965).

Application denied.