Maryland case law › Swann v. State

Swann v. State

192 Md. 9 (1949) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DismissedMarkell, J.✓ Good law
SummaryAppellant Swann and Clarence Ross were convicted by the court, sitting as a jury, of breaking the storehouse (a tavern) of Edwin A. Blandford with intent to steal goods of the value of $25 or more. Swann was sentenced to ten years in the penitentiary. Charles Joseph Hawkins and Paul Revere Hodge were indicted for receiving stolen goods and, after Swann's conviction, pleaded guilty and received suspended sentences. On appeal, Swann contended he was convicted on the uncorroborated testimony of Hawkins and Hodge, alleged accomplices. The Court of Appeals assumed without deciding that Hawkins and Hodge could be regarded as accomplices, citing Luery v. State. The Court acknowledged that it had approved the view that a conviction on the uncorroborated evidence of accomplices ought not to stand (Lanasa v. State), but explained that in Maryland the jury are the judges of law as well as of fact,
Questions presented
  • Whether a conviction may stand on the uncorroborated testimony of accomplices.
  • Whether the sufficiency of corroboration of accomplice testimony is reviewable on appeal.
  • Whether the record presents any ruling of the lower court for review.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Markell, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Appellant and Clarence Ross were found guilty by the court, sitting as a jury, of breaking the storehouse (a tavern) of Edwin A. Blandford with intent to steal, take and carry away certain goods and chattels of another of the value of $25 or more. Appellant was sentenced to ten years in the penitentiary. From this judgment he appeals.

Charles Joseph Hawkins and Paul Revere Hodge were indicted for receiving stolen goods and after appellant’s conviction pleaded guilty and were given suspended sentences. Appellant says he was convicted on the uncorroborated testimony of Hawkins and Hodge, accomplices in his alleged crime. We may assume, without deciding, that Hawkins and Hodge may be regarded as accomplices. Luery v. State, 116 Md. 284, 295, 296 , 81 A. 681, 685 , Ann. Cas. 1913D, 161.

This court has approved the view that a conviction on the uncorroborated evidence of accomplices ought not to stand. Lanasa v. State, 109 Md. 602, 613 , 71 A. 1058 . But in Maryland the .jury are the judges of law, as well 11 as of fact, including the legal questions of sufficiency of evidence to convict or to corroborate evidence of accomplices. The verdict of the jury on such questions is not reviewable on appeal.

Under existing practice, the verdict of the court, sitting as a jury, is like the verdict of a jury in this respect (Meyerson v. State, 181 Md. 105, 112 , 28 A. 2d 833 ; Wolf v. State, 143 Md. 489 -504, 122 A. 641 ) and a court cannot be required to instruct the jury, even though this court has recommended that the trial courts adopt the practice of granting advisory instructions advising or cautioning jurors against conviction without corroboration. Luery v. State, 116 Md. 284, 293, 294 , 81 A. 681, 685 , Ann. Cas. 1913D, 161. The question of sufficiency of corroboration can also be reviewed on motion for a new trial, but action on such a motion is not reviewable on appeal. Wolf v. State, supra.

In the instant case no ruling of the lower court, reviewable on appeal or not, is even presented for review. The record shows that at the conclusion of the State’s case, counsel for appellant “commented on lack of corroboration of testimony of Hodge and Hawkins”, but does not show that any objection was made to any ruling by the court. Since the record presents no ruling by the court objected to by appellant, there is nothing before us and the appeal must be dismissed. Davis v. State, 189 Md. 269 , 55 A. 2d 702 .

Appeal dismissed, with costs.