Maryland case law › Tate v. State

Tate v. State

229 Md. 454 (1962) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedPer Curiam✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant was convicted of robbery by a jury in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County. His sole contention on appeal was that the trial judge, over his objection, erroneously permitted a police officer to testify that the prosecuting witness had identified the appellant when he was first taken to the Dundalk Police Station. The appellant argued that the State failed to prove the prior-to-trial identification was made under circumstances establishing its fairness, integrity, and reliability. The Court of Appeals noted it had addressed this proposition in at least four recent cases—Basoff v. State, Judy v. State, Bulluck v. State, and Proctor v. State—but found it unnecessary to discuss the proposition because, assuming without deciding that the trial judge erroneously admitted the testimony, the error was harmless. The Court reasoned that the prosecuting witness testified he had know
Questions presented
  • Whether the trial judge erred in permitting a police officer to testify, over objection, that the prosecuting witness had identified the appellant when he was first taken to the Dundalk Police Station, where the State allegedly failed to prove the prior-to-trial identification was made under circumstances establishing its fairness, integrity and reliability.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. Appellant was convicted of robbery by a jury in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County. His only complaint on this appeal is that the trial judge, over his objection, permitted one of the police officers to testify that the prosecuting witness had identified appellant when he was first taken to the Dundalk Police Station. He contends the State failed to prove the prior-to-trial identification was made under circumstances which established its fairness, integrity and reliability.

This Court has had occasion to deal with this proposition, in, at least, four recent cases: Basoff v. State, 208 Md. 643 , 119 A. 2d 917 ; Judy v. State, 218 Md. 168 , 146 A. 2d 29 ; Bulluck v. State, 219 Md. 67 , 148 A. 2d 433 ; and Proctor v. State, 223 Md. 394 , 164 A. 2d 708 . However, in the view that we take of the instant case, we find it unnecessary to discuss the proposition; because, if we assume, without deciding, that the trial judge erroneously admitted the testimony, the error was, we think, harmless. The prosecuting witness testified that he had known appellant and his co-defendant for some time (and knew his name) prior to 456 the robbery. The appellant admitted this acquaintanceship between him and his accuser.

The prosecuting witness testified further that he had informed the officers before appellant's arrest that he would be able to identify appellant, and he had made a positive identification of the accused at the trial. Under these circumstances, the testimony objected to was merely cumulative, and, in our judgment, not prejudicial. Judgment affirmed.